Stand on Guard

Stand on Guard · For the people paying the bill

No thank you.

We’re polite. We’re Canadian. And we’re done voting for the lesser of two evils.

Since 2015. Here’s what you got.

11 years. One party. No thank you.

Temporary residents: Statistics Canada, July 1, 2026 (2.78 million). Toronto: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census (2,794,356). Population: Statistics Canada, July 1 estimates (35.7 million in 2015, 41.7 million in 2025). 2027 permanent residents, up to 662,000: see “Officially 380,000. Up to 662,000.” in the immigration section. Every other number is sourced in its section below.

Search everything

It’s all here. Find the part that makes you angriest.

On a pedestal

What they tell you. What their own numbers say.

Every claim here came from Ottawa. So did every answer: its own departments, its own budget, the budget officer Parliament pays to check it.

Sources: Prime Minister Mark Carney, House of Commons, Nov. 5, 2026; IRCC Annual Report to Parliament on Immigration (2025 full-year permit holders and asylum claims); Immigration Levels Plan 2026–2028 (380,000 target for 2027); Budget 2025 and Budget 2026 (one-time permanent residence measures); Parliamentary Budget Officer, fiscal analysis of Budget 2026 (Nov. 2026) and Alto high-speed rail cost analysis (Oct. 1, 2026); Liberal Party platform, 2015 (balanced budget by 2019); Department of Finance, Fiscal Reference Tables. Each row links to its section and full sources.

Immigration · 2015 → 2025

Trudeau · 2015–25
Carney · 2025–

Too many, too fast. Nobody asked for it.

3.2%Population growth in 2023 · 1.27 million people in one year. More than all of Ottawa. Fastest since 1957
98%Of that growth came from immigration. Not births. Without temporary residents it would have been 1.2%
2.8MOn temporary permits right now. Equal to every man, woman and child in Toronto · 2.78M vs. 2.79M, July 1, 2026

Canada’s population · July 1, 2000 → 2025 · and where the old pace would have put us

30M35M40M200020052010201520202025THE OLD PACE · 39.1MACTUAL · 41.7M+2.6MABOVE THE OLD PACE30.7MTRUDEAUSWORN IN NOV 2015CARNEYMAR 2025

35.7 million in 2015. 41.7 million in 2025. Almost 6 million more people in ten years, against about 3.5 million the decade before. At the pace Canada grew from 2000 to 2015, we’d be at about 39.1 million today. That’s 2.6 million extra people, and most of them arrived after 2021. Ask where the extra doctors, hospital beds and homes are.

People added to Canada, every year · July to July

2000–2015 AVERAGE · ~335K A YEAR00/0104/0509/10270K14/1519/20710K1.10M1.21M389K*24/253.6× THE OLD NORMALTRUDEAUSWORN IN NOV 2015CARNEYMAR 2025

For fifteen years, Canada added about 335,000 people a year (the dashed line). Then 2022/23 added 1.1 million, and 2023/24 added 1.2 million, roughly the population of Saskatchewan, in twelve months.

* 2024/25 is Statistics Canada’s estimate. It counts expiring permits as people leaving the country.

Where 2023’s growth came from · Jan 1 2023 → Jan 1 2024

805KTemporary residents · students, workers, asylum claimants · 61%
472KPermanent immigrants · 36%
31KBirths over deaths · 2%

Most of the growth wasn’t permanent immigration at all. It was 805,000 more people on temporary permits, in one year. That’s why the permanent numbers can look calm while the population explodes. Temporary residents use the same roads, rents, clinics and ERs.

They told you the number they wanted you to watch.472,000 permanent.Not the 805,000 temporary.Not the 23,500 nobody can find.

Temporary residents living in Canada · July 1, every year

2015 LEVEL · 750K283K20002005201020151.06M20201.55M2.20M2.78M2026PEAK · 2.98M · OCT 2024ALMOST 4× THE 2015 LEVEL · NO TARGET UNTIL 2024TRUDEAUSWORN IN NOV 2015CARNEYMAR 2025EVERY PERSON IN TORONTO · 2.79M

See where the bars hit the white line? Equal to every man, woman and child in Toronto, living here on a temporary permit. Ottawa set a target for permanent residents every year. For temporary residents there was no target at all until 2024. It crept up for fifteen years, from 283,000 in 2000 to 750,000 in 2015. Then it nearly quadrupled, to almost 3 million. The cuts so far have only taken it back to where it was in spring 2024. Not 2015.

Temporary residents: work permit and study permit holders, asylum claimants and their families, living in Canada on July 1. Statistics Canada changed how it counts them in 2023 and revised every figure from 2021 on in September 2026, adding about 240,000 people. 2000–2018 use its older method; 2019–2020 are its older figures plus its published yearly change.

New permanent residents, every year · and what Ottawa has planned

2000–2014 AVERAGE · ~248K A YEAR200020052010260K2015185K2020484K394K2025UP TO662K20294 RECORDS IN A ROW · THE OLD ONE WAS SET IN 1913PLANNED · 380K TARGET, UP TO 422KTRUDEAUSWORN IN NOV 2015CARNEYMAR 2025

About 250,000 a year for fifteen years. Then four straight records. Then Ottawa slammed the brakes, to 380,000 a year. Now look at 2027: 380,000, plus up to 282,000 people already here made permanent outside the target. Up to 662,000, more than any year in Canadian history. Dotted bars are Ottawa’s targets; the lines above them are the official range. And the targets keep getting topped up: one-time extras of 148,000 were added for 2026–27, then 200,000 more for 2027. Don’t expect 2028 to be the first year it doesn’t happen. And on Nov. 9, a week after the budget, Ottawa made its rural pilot permanent: another pathway for employers to turn people on temporary permits into permanent residents.

He says · His own department says

Mark Carney

He says 80%. His own department says 26%.

In the House on Nov. 5, the Prime Minister said he’d taken back control of immigration. Here’s the full year his own department reported to Parliament.

He said, Nov. 5The full year, 2025
Foreign students80% down26% down516,275 → 381,725 study permit holders
Temporary foreign workers60% down18% down905,440 → 743,770 work permits
Asylum claims70% down34% down173,000 → 114,515 claims

In September he told the New York Times 60%, 50% and a third. Two months later it was 80%, 60% and 70%. No new full-year numbers came out in between. He didn’t say what he was comparing.

What we’re not saying: that nothing has dropped. New students arriving fell about 61% in 2025, and asylum claims are down a third.

What we are saying: pick the best month and any number looks good. The full year is what his own department reported, and it’s a fraction of what he claims.

The taps, renamed

Officially 380,000. Up to 662,000.

Ottawa says it cut immigration. It kept the number it announces and opened side doors that don’t count against it.

380K
Ottawa’s official permanent resident target for 2027.
662K
What 2027 could be once you count the side doors.
200,000
“Longstanding temporary residents”Budget 2026

Made permanent by the end of 2027. Not counted in the target.

115,000
Protected personsBudget 2025

A “one-time” measure over 2026 and 2027. Not counted in the target.

33,000
Work permit holdersBudget 2025

Another “one-time” measure, same two years.

114,515
Asylum claims2025

No cap. Ottawa’s own briefing says there is no limit on how many claims it takes in a year.

385,000
New temporary residents2026 target

Still arriving, on top of all of it.

What we’re not saying: the conversions are people already living here, not new arrivals, and asylum claims fell by a third in 2025.

What we are saying: the target is the number they announce, not the number that stays. Every person converted is here for good, and the 380,000 never counts them.

The 5% promise

His promise

They promised fewer temporary residents. They’re changing the label.

Ottawa promised to get temporary residents under 5% of the population by 2027. One way it gets there: make them permanent. Same people, same homes, same line at the doctor. They just stop counting as temporary.

6.8%
Temporary residents, share of the population. December 2025.
200K
Already here, made permanent by the end of 2027. Every one comes off the temporary count.

Getting from 6.8% to 5% means about 750,000 fewer people counted as temporary. At least 200,000 of that is a new label, not a person leaving. More than a quarter of the promise, kept on paper.

What we’re not saying: that nobody is leaving. Over a million permits expire this year, and some of those people do go home.

What we are saying: when they announce they hit 5%, check the total. A smaller “temporary” number isn’t fewer people.

Where it’s coming from · new permanent residents, 2015 vs 2023

20152023India39,340139,7753.6×Philippines50,84026,955China19,46031,780United States7,65510,640France5,85010,075
14%Of new permanent residents from India · 2015
30%From India · 2023 · 139,775 people
#1India was also the top source of study permits (189,135) and new work permits (249,570) · 2024

1 in 7 became nearly 1 in 3. This isn’t about the people. It’s about a system that ran on one pipeline: student visas into colleges, then work permits, then permanent residence. Ottawa built that, then lost control of it.

The ones nobody’s counting

How many people are here illegally? Ottawa doesn’t know.

23,500Former students who had to leave in 2024 · no record they did · Auditor General, 2026
153,000Students flagged as possibly breaking permit rules, 2023–24 · funding to investigate 2,000 a year
34,630People wanted for removal, whereabouts unknown · CBSA, Oct 2026

Ottawa’s own estimate: as many as 500,000 people living here without status. Statistics Canada has only just started its first-ever count. Meanwhile CBSA removed a record 23,000 people in 2025, and its list of people waiting to be removed is still more than double what it was five years ago.

CBSA says some unmatched exit records may be people who did leave. That’s the point: nobody can say for sure.

Under the surface · From Ottawa’s own records

A system that can’t see itself. And people selling the way in.

546,962
People on CBSA’s removal booksOct. 31, 2026

Most can’t be acted on yet, usually because a refugee claim is pending. 84,125 can: 49,495 being processed and 34,630 who didn’t show up. At 2025’s record pace of 23,160 a year, that’s more than three and a half years of work, if nobody new is added.

3.7×
Foreign students claiming asylum5,290 in 2022 → 19,685 in 2025

They came to study, then asked for refugee protection. In 2024 the top colleges for claims were Conestoga (720) and Seneca (650), both in Ontario.

$45,000
Price of a job offerSold online, CBC investigation

Employers and consultants sold the paperwork foreign workers need to come here, for jobs that sometimes didn’t exist. Ottawa doesn’t publish how much of this fraud it finds.

1.8M
Temporary permits expiring in 2026After 2.1 million in 2025

Asked how many people actually left when their permits ran out, then-immigration minister Marc Miller told MPs: “We don’t have that number.”

153,324
Students flagged by their own schools2023 and 2024 · Auditor General

Ottawa had money to check about 2,000 a year. Of the cases it finished, more than half never answered. It confirmed 50.

105
Caught lying. Then made permanent.Auditor General, March 2026

800 study permits were obtained with fake documents or lies. 92% of those people applied to stay longer. 105 became permanent residents. One is confirmed to have left Canada.

16,000
Confirmed gone, of 39,500 who had to leaveStudents whose permits ran out in 2024

The other 23,500: nobody can say. The Auditor General found the department had no way to know.

What we’re not saying: that these are bad people. Most temporary residents follow the rules, and many who claim asylum are found to be real refugees. Removals are at a record high.

What we are saying: a country that can’t say who’s here, who left, or who bought their way in hasn’t taken back control of anything.

Two sets of rules · From the courts’ own rulings

Judge: five years is fit. Sentence: four.

August 2026. An Ontario judge convicted a permanent resident of sexual assault causing bodily harm. She said five years was a fit sentence. Then she cut a year, because he could be deported.

2013
The rule that allows itR. v. Pham, Supreme Court of Canada

Judges may lower a non-citizen’s sentence because of what it means for deportation, as long as it stays “proportionate.”

6 months
The line lawyers aim underImmigration and Refugee Protection Act

More than six months in jail and a non-citizen faces deportation for serious criminality. Defence lawyers argue for five months and 29 days.

0
Days that house arrest counts as jailTran v. Canada, Supreme Court, 2017

A conditional sentence isn’t a “term of imprisonment” for deportation. So house arrest keeps the door open.

158–171
The one-line fix, voted downBill C-220 · March 25, 2026

“A court… shall not take into consideration” a sentence’s effect on immigration status. Defeated by 13 votes.

The same day, the House passed C-9. It removed a defence for good-faith religious speech that had been in Canada’s hate speech law since 1970. It’s now law.

It’s not one judge

Case after case. Same reason: deportation.

No conviction
Calgary, 2024Alberta Court of Justice

A man here on a visitor permit grabbed an 18-year-old woman at a bar. The Crown asked for 15 to 45 days in jail. The judge gave a conditional discharge, so no conviction was recorded.

No jail
Quebec, May 2026Court of Quebec

A temporary resident’s violent domestic assault, which the judge called “neither trivial nor minimal.” Conditional discharge and probation, after weighing his plan to apply for permanent residence.

Reduced
Quebec Court of Appeal, Sept. 2026Aggravated assault

She disfigured a stranger in a biting attack. Her sentence was cut because prison would endanger her “precarious immigration status.”

3 months off
Ontario Court of Appeal, 2015Armed bank robbery

The getaway driver’s nine months was cut to just under six.

Under 6 months
P.E.I. Court of Appeal, 2017Assault on a woman

Cut, in the court’s words, partly “to give him a chance to remain in Canada.”

Even prosecutors do it. In April 2026, a Montreal judge accused Crown prosecutors of often recommending lighter sentences for people at risk of deportation. The Crown says no such directive exists.

The Globe and Mail’s editorial board, November 2025: “Judges in too many cases are protecting non-citizens from the consequences of their criminal conduct.”

What we’re not saying: that judges let people off. The sentence still has to fit the crime, and the Supreme Court said these consequences can’t be used to dodge Parliament’s rules.

What we are saying: two people, same crime, different sentence. One law for everyone.

What they get, and when · Ontario

Are they getting health care from day one? Most of them, yes. Citizenship? No.

2.8 million here on temporary permits right now. Equal to every man, woman and child in Toronto. That’s workers, students, asylum claimants and their families, and it’s a snapshot: people leave, new ones arrive. Permanent residents are different. They add up every year and they stay: 3.6 million from 2016 to 2025.

Health careCash benefitsCitizenship
Permanent residents3.6M since 2016 · 380K+ a year
YESDay one. Ontario dropped its 3-month wait in 2020
YESDay one. Canada Child Benefit included
NO3 years in Canada first (1,095 days)
Work permit holders1.5M here now
YESOHIP with a full-time Ontario job of 6+ months. No waiting period
18 MONTHSCanada Child Benefit, after 18 months in Canada
NOTime counts half, up to 1 year
International students620K here now
NONot OHIP. School health plans
18 MONTHSCanada Child Benefit, after 18 months in Canada
NOTime counts half, up to 1 year
Asylum claimants300K+ claims waiting
YESDay they file. Federal plan (IFHP): 623,365 people covered, $896.5M in 2024–25
YESOntario Works welfare from the day they claim
NOOnly if accepted, then the same 3 years

Do the math: a temporary worker with a full-time job gets OHIP with no waiting period. Then everyone joins the same line: a median 28.6 weeks for treatment after a referral. So how do our hospitals fill up? Not by people skipping the line. By 1.2 million people arriving in one year, into a system that already made us wait 28.6 weeks for treatment, with no plan for more doctors, beds or homes. Ottawa set the numbers. Nobody did the math on the services.

Health care for asylum claimants · The Interim Federal Health Program

$3 million a day. Including for people told to leave.

Claimants get federal coverage the day they file: hospital and doctor visits, plus prescriptions, dental, vision and counselling that most Canadians pay for themselves. It runs while the claim waits, and often after it fails.

$3M
A day this year. The budget watchdog projects $1.104 billion for 2026–27.
51,188
Failed claimants under removal orders who can stay covered until they leave. 27,759 of them are wanted on immigration warrants.
$275M+
Health care for rejected claimantsIRCC, April 2026

Ten years of coverage for people the refugee board turned down. About $10 million in 2016–17. Over $53 million in 2024–25.

$257M
Dental, in one year2024–25

Urgent dental care for claimants. It was $30 million in 2019–20.

4 years
Average time on the plan2024–25

Up from three years in 2021–22. The longer a claim waits, the longer you pay.

530,090
Claimants and protected persons living hereJuly 1, 2026

The first quarterly drop since 2022, down 7,015. Still more than half a million.

$1.522B
Where it’s headed2029–30

The watchdog’s projection, from $211 million in 2020–21. A new co-payment trims $217 million a year by then.

Sources: Parliamentary Budget Officer, Projecting the Cost of the Interim Federal Health Program (Feb 12, 2026; $1,104M in 2026–27, $1,522M in 2029–30); Parliamentary Budget Officer, Reviewing the Administrative and Fiscal Impacts of the Interim Federal Health Program (May 26, 2026; CBSA removals inventory Dec 2025: 23,429 removals in progress, 27,759 wanted, eligible until departure; urgent dental $30M to $257M; average coverage about four years; co-payment saves $217M a year by 2029–30); IRCC response to order paper question from MP Burton Bailey (April 2026; $275M+ for claimants rejected by the IRB, 2016–17 to 2024–25); Statistics Canada, Canada’s population estimates, Sept 23, 2026 (530,090 on July 1, 2026). Daily figure is our math: $1,104M ÷ 365.

Who we let in · who we turn away

We fast-tracked fast-food workers. We turned away Canadian kids who want to be doctors.

49×Food counter attendants approved as temporary foreign workers, 2018 to 2023. From 170 to 8,333.
1 in 5Canadians who apply to medical school get a seat. More than 15,000 apply for fewer than 3,000 spots.
1 in 4Canadian doctors trained abroad who get to work here

Canada has 2.7 practising doctors per 1,000 people. The OECD average is 3.9. We graduate about half as many new doctors per person as the average rich country: 7.5 per 100,000, against 14.2. The fix isn’t more people. It’s training our own.

Sources: CBC News, June 2024, from Employment and Social Development Canada data (food counter attendants approved: 170 in 2018, 8,333 in 2023); The Globe and Mail (low-wage stream approvals 28,121 in 2019, 83,643 in 2023); Leland, 2026 (more than 15,000 applicants for fewer than 3,000 first-year medical seats); CBC News, 2023 (Canadians studying medicine abroad: 26% matched to a Canadian residency; citizens and permanent residents only); OECD, Health at a Glance 2025 (2.7 practising doctors per 1,000 in Canada, OECD average 3.9); Fraser Institute, citing OECD data (7.5 medical graduates per 100,000 in Canada in 2023, OECD average 14.2). IRCC, Nov. 9, 2026 (Rural Community Immigration Pilot made permanent; 5,500 permanent residence spaces in the 2027–2029 levels plan). Ontario Ministry of Health, OHIP eligibility (valid work permit and full-time work for an Ontario employer for at least six months; Ontario removed its three-month waiting period in 2020). Century Initiative: Global News and The Canadian Press, Oct. 2016 (founders, growth council roles; Barton: the 100 million goal “didn’t come up”); Advisory Council on Economic Growth, Attracting the Talent Canada Needs, Oct. 2016 (450,000 a year); The Logic, 2019 (founded by six executives; Barton named ambassador to China); Prime Minister’s Office, Dec. 22, 2025 (Wiseman named ambassador to the U.S., starting Feb. 15, 2026); IRCC permanent residents, 2023 (471,771). The Canadian Press, Dec. 2025 (Wiseman a longtime friend of Carney; $1,750 to his leadership bid and $1,750 to the Liberal Party, from Elections Canada records); Prime Minister’s Office, March 2025 (Canada–U.S. council) and Aug. 31, 2026 (Barton named chair of Invest in Canada, part-time, three years); The Logic, Sept. 3, 2026 (Barton remains chair of Rio Tinto); House of Commons committee testimony, Feb. 2023 (Barton: “I am not a member or supporter of any political party”; also advised the Harper government).; House of Commons, Oral Questions, Nov. 5, 2026 (the Prime Minister: asylum seekers down 70%, temporary foreign workers 60%, foreign students 80%); The Hub, Oct. 16, 2026, on his Sept. 23 New York Times interview (students 60%, temporary foreign workers 50%); IRCC, Annual Reports to Parliament on Immigration, 2025 and 2026 (study permit holders 516,275 in 2024 and 381,725 in 2025; work permits 905,440 and 743,770); IRCC briefing note on asylum, Apr. 30, 2026 (claims 173,000 and 114,515); IRCC via The Tribune, 2026 (new student arrivals 61% lower in 2025); CBSA, Removals statistics, Table 6.1 (removal sub-inventories as of Oct. 31, 2026: not yet actionable 416,124, removal not possible 46,713, wanted 34,630, removal in progress 49,495, total 546,962) and enforced removals by year (23,160 in 2025; 18,275 to Oct. 31, 2026); Global News, from IRCC data (student asylum claims 5,290 in 2022, 13,075 in 2023, 20,245 in 2024; Conestoga 720, Seneca 650 in 2024); IRCC, briefing to the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration, March 23, 2026 (about 19,685 claims by study permit holders in 2025); CBC/Investigative Journalism Foundation, 2024 (job offers sold for up to $45,000); HCAMag/CBC (ESDC does not release public data on LMIA fraud); IRCC data via CityNews and Nairametrics (about 2.1 million temporary permits expiring in 2025 and 1.8 million in 2026); House of Commons immigration committee (then-minister Marc Miller: “We don’t have that number”); IRCC, 2026–2028 Immigration Levels Plan, and Prime Minister’s commitment to bring temporary residents below 5% of the population by the end of 2027; temporary residents about 6.8% of the population as of December 2025 (Statistics Canada estimates); Budget 2026, Chapter 3, and IRCC backgrounder with the 2027–2029 Immigration Levels Plan, Nov. 5, 2026 (up to 200,000 temporary residents already in Canada to become permanent residents by the end of 2027). 1.8 percentage points × 41.7 million ≈ 750,000.; Auditor General of Canada, 2026 Report, International Student Program Reforms, March 23, 2026 (153,324 potentially non-compliant students reported in 2023 and 2024; funding for about 2,000 investigations a year; 3,105 completed, 1,654 no response, 50 confirmed non-compliant; 800 permits issued 2018–2023 with fraudulent documents or misrepresentation, 92% applied for other permits, 124 applied for permanent residence and 105 were approved, 1 confirmed to have left Canada); The Canadian Press, March 23, 2026 (549,000 study permits expiring in 2024; 39,500 required to leave; about 16,000 confirmed by CBSA to have left); R. v. Pham, 2013 SCC 15 (a sentencing judge may take collateral immigration consequences into account, provided the sentence is proportionate); Tran v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2017 SCC 50 (a conditional sentence is not a “term of imprisonment” under IRPA s. 36(1)(a)); Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, s. 36(1)(a) (term of imprisonment of more than six months); Canadian Immigration Lawyers Association, 2025 (defence submissions of five months and 29 days); National Post via Unpublished, Aug. 20, 2026, R. v. Reyes Loor, Ontario Superior Court (“five years is a fit and appropriate sentence”; “I decrease the sentence to four years”); Parliament of Canada, LEGISinfo, Bill C-220 (defeated at second reading March 25, 2026, 158–171); Bill C-9, Combatting Hate Act (third reading March 25, 2026; royal assent June 18, 2026, S.C. 2026, c. 15; religious-text defence not restored, per Canadian Council of Christian Charities, June 2026); The Globe and Mail, editorial, Nov. 25, 2025 (Calgary, 2024: visitor-permit holder, sexual touching of an 18-year-old at a bar, conditional discharge by Justice Anne Brown, Crown sought 15 to 45 days; Ontario Court of Appeal, 2015: getaway driver in an armed bank robbery, nine months reduced to just under six); National Post via Unpublished, May 30, 2026 (Court of Quebec, temporary resident, conditional discharge and three years’ probation for violent domestic assault and harassment; judge reviewed impact on his plan to apply for permanent residency); National Post, Sept. 2026 (Quebec Court of Appeal reduced sentence for biting attack on the grounds a harsher term would endanger the offender’s “precarious immigration status”); CBC News, Oct. 11, 2017 (P.E.I. Court of Appeal reduced an assault sentence to six months less a day, in part to give the offender a chance to remain in Canada); CTV News, April 10, 2026 (Quebec judge accuses Montreal prosecutors of recommending lower sentences to prevent deportations; Crown denies any directive)

Who’s pushing it · The Century Initiative

100 million Canadians by 2100. Its founders keep getting government jobs.

A lobby group that wants nearly triple today’s population, mostly through immigration. Co-founded by Dominic Barton, then head of McKinsey, and Mark Wiseman, a former head of the Canada Pension Plan’s investment board.

450K
Immigrants a year. What the founders’ growth council told Ottawa to take, in 2016.
471,771
What Ottawa took by 2023.

Two founders. Six government posts.

DB
Dominic Barton

Dominic Barton

Then head of McKinsey

  1. 2016–17Chair, Ottawa’s Advisory Council on Economic Growth
  2. 2019–21Ambassador to China
  3. NowChair, Invest in Canada. Carney’s pick, Sept. 2026

Still chairs Rio Tinto.

MW
Mark Wiseman

Mark Wiseman

Carney’s longtime friend

  1. 2016Member, the same growth council
  2. 2025Carney’s Canada–U.S. advisory council
  3. NowAmbassador to the United States, leading the CUSMA talks

Gave the maximum to Carney’s leadership run.

What we’re not saying: Ottawa never adopted the 100 million target. Barton said it didn’t come up at the growth council, and Carney has distanced himself from the group. Barton says he supports no party, and he advised Harper’s government too.

What we are saying: the people who want three times as many Canadians keep getting the government’s ear, and the numbers went their way.

Wave after wave

One wave settles. Wave after wave, the shore never does.

Newcomers fit in when there’s time to. When the next wave is always coming, nobody has to.

30,000
People surveyedHarvard, Robert Putnam, 2007

The biggest study of its kind. The more diverse the neighbourhood, the less people trusted their neighbours. Even neighbours from their own group. He found trust can rebuild over time.

40 yrs
America’s pause1924 to 1965

After its great wave, the U.S. cut immigration hard for four decades. The melting pot did its melting while the taps were mostly off.

1991
Quebec picks its ownCanada–Quebec Accord

Quebec selects its own economic immigrants, to integrate them and protect its distinct identity. Ottawa signed it.

6M
The rest of Canada2015 to 2025

Almost 6 million more people in ten years. No pause.

Quebec gets to protect its culture. Why doesn’t the rest of Canada?

What we’re not saying: that diversity is the problem. Putnam found communities can rebuild trust over time.

What we are saying: it takes time, and it takes a break between waves. Ten years of record growth gives neither.

Buy-in

Any good job makes you earn it. Canada should too.

Try landing a good job. An application, a screening call, rounds of interviews, references, a background check. Weeks or months of it, and most people never hear back.

Canada asks a new resident for less.

And every good company hires different people who share the same values. That’s the whole trick. Canada stopped asking about the values.

We don’t care where you come from. If you’re coming to Canada, we want you to want Canada.

QuebecSince 2020, economic immigrants must pass a values test before they’re selected.
AustraliaMost visa applicants sign an Australian Values Statement, every time they apply.
OttawaNothing at the door. The first civics test comes at citizenship, years after you arrive.

The fix

  1. 01Fewer people, chosen on purpose. Permanent levels set to what housing, hospitals and jobs can carry, published with the math.
  2. 02The deal, in writing. A Canadian values statement signed with every visa and permanent residence application. Know it. Sign it. Mean it.
  3. 03Train our own. Open more medical school seats for Canadians.Our position
  4. 04Bring our kids home. More residency spots for Canadians who studied medicine abroad.Our position
  5. 05No low-wage foreign workers for fast food.Our position
  6. 06Count everyone. Every conversion counts against the target, and the total population is published right beside it.Our position
  7. 07Let the pace match the place. Quebec picks its own immigrants to protect its culture. Every province should get the same say.Our position
  8. 08One law for all. Immigration status never shortens a sentence.Our position
  9. 09Fail the claim, lose the extras. Emergency care only once a claim is rejected. No better coverage than Canadians get.Our position

Sources: Statistics Canada, Table 17-10-0005-01 (July 1 population estimates, 2000–2025), annual demographic estimates (2016–2022) and population estimates (March 27, 2024; Sept 24, 2025; Dec 17, 2025); Statistics Canada, 150 years of immigration in Canada (admissions 2000–2014); IRCC annual reports to Parliament (permanent resident admissions 2015–2025); IRCC data via CIC News and Saint Mary’s University ARGEIAD (source countries, study and work permits, 2024); Statistics Canada, population estimates, Sept 23, 2026 (41,798,407 people and 2,779,774 non-permanent residents on July 1, 2026; 6.7%); Statistics Canada, population estimates, Mar 27, 2024 (2023 growth of 1,271,872; 97.6% from international migration; 1.2% without temporary immigration); Statistics Canada, 2021 Census (City of Ottawa, 1,017,449); IRCC 2025 Annual Report to Parliament (3.3 million permit holders); CIC News, Nov 5, 2026 (up to 622,000 in 2027); Library of Parliament (1913 record); IRCC 2026–2028 and 2027–2029 Immigration Levels Plans (Nov 5, 2026, including the time-limited measure of up to 200,000 additional permanent residence spaces in 2027); IRCC data via immigration.ca (source countries, 2015 vs 2023 and 2024); Quebec Ministry of Immigration (values attestation, 2020); Australia Department of Home Affairs (Australian Values Statement); Ontario.ca, Apply for OHIP (no waiting period; work permit eligibility); Canada Revenue Agency, Canada Child Benefit eligibility (18-month rule); IRCC, citizenship eligibility (1,095 days); IRCC, Interim Federal Health Program, briefing to the Senate, Feb 9, 2026; City of Ottawa, Ontario Works eligibility for refugee claimants; Auditor General of Canada, International Student Program Reforms, March 2026 (549,000 expired permits, 39,500 required to leave, 16,000 confirmed departures, 153,000 flagged); CBSA removals inventory, Oct 31, 2025, and briefing to the Public Safety committee, April 30, 2026; IRCC estimate of up to 500,000 undocumented people; CBSA removal-in-progress inventory (over 30,000, Nov 2025); Statistics Canada first count of overstays (Nov 2026); Statistics Canada, Population Projections Technical Report 2018–2068, ch. 7, Figure 7.1 (temporary residents 2000–2018); Statistics Canada, The Daily, Sept 29, 2020 (net temporary residents 2018/2019 and 2019/2020); Statistics Canada, Table 17-10-0121-01 via Moving2Canada tracker and The Daily, Sept 23, 2026 (temporary residents 2021–2026, revised; Oct 1, 2024 peak); Statistics Canada population estimates for July 1, 2026, via Scotiabank Economics, Sept 24, 2026 (1,496,248 work permit holders; 619,903 study permit holders); Canada Revenue Agency, Canada Child Benefit eligibility (temporary residents: 18 months in Canada).; Budget 2025 and Budget 2026, Chapter 3 (one-time and temporary-to-permanent measures); IRCC, Immigration Levels Plan 2026–2028 (temporary resident targets); IRCC, briefing note on asylum for the Commons public safety committee, Apr. 30, 2026 (claims, 2024–2025) and Minister’s transition binder, May 2025 (no cap on claims); The Hub, Nov. 12, 2026 (2027 total of up to 662,000); Robert D. Putnam, “E Pluribus Unum: Diversity and Community in the Twenty-first Century,” Scandinavian Political Studies, June 2007 (about 30,000 people, 41 U.S. communities; lower trust, including within groups; long-run optimism); U.S. Immigration Act of 1924 and Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965; Canada–Québec Accord relating to Immigration and Temporary Admission of Aliens, Feb. 5, 1991 (canada.ca); IRCC, Quebec key facts, briefing for the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration, Apr. 22, 2026 (Accord objectives: preserve Quebec’s demographic weight and integrate immigrants while respecting its distinct identity; Quebec selects economic immigrants)

Jobs · January to October 2026

America added 861,000 jobs this year. Canada lost 46,000.

Total jobs gained or lost since December 2025 · thousands

−200K0+200K+400K+600K+800KDec ’25JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOct ’26U.S.+861KCanada−46K−200K0+200K+400K+600K+800KDec ’25MayOct ’26U.S.+861KCanada−46K
6.7%Unemployment, October 2026. The highest in six months.
13.7%Of young Canadians, 15 to 24, can’t find work. October 2026.
1.5MPeople here on work permits, competing for the same jobs. July 2026.

Plant by plant · coast to coast

From B.C. mills to Quebec factories. 61,000 manufacturing jobs gone since January 2025.

54,000
QuebecAugust 2025 to August 2026

Jobs lost over the year. The only province to go backwards.

15,000
B.C. forestrySince 2022

21 mills closed, by the industry’s own count. Lumber duties, low prices and a shortage of timber.

49,000
Chinese EVs let in, every yearTariff cut from 100% to 6.1% · rising to 70,000

About three in four cars built in Canada go to the U.S., which keeps a 100% tariff on Chinese EVs. Ontario’s premier warned the deal risks closing that door.

3,000
StellantisBrampton, Ont.

Jeep Compass moved to Illinois. Workers idle since 2023 won’t go back.

1,000
Algoma SteelSault Ste. Marie, Ont.

Blast furnace shut. The CEO says tariffs “closed off” the U.S. market.

1,000
GMOshawa, Ont.

Third shift cut while GM added capacity in Indiana.

500
CanforVanderhoof and Fort St. John, B.C.

Two sawmills closed, citing U.S. duties.

up to 500
StelcoHamilton, Ont.

Layoffs, two years into a five-year promise to Ottawa to keep Canadian jobs.

350
StanpacSmithville, Ont.

70% of its workforce. Equipment moves to the U.S. Dec. 1.

300
Canfor Northwood pulp millPrince George, B.C.

Closing for good by late 2026.

300
PACCARSainte-Thérèse, Que.

Truck plant layoffs tied to U.S. heavy-truck tariffs.

200+
Crown RoyalAmherstburg, Ont.

Production moved to the U.S. Turned down Ontario’s offers.

Fewer jobs. More people chasing them. Ottawa kept handing out work permits while hiring stalled, and the first to get squeezed out are young Canadians looking for their first job. 78% of work permits in 2025 skipped the check for a Canadian who could do the job. Ottawa froze low-wage foreign hiring in 30 of 41 cities. It left small towns open, and never touched that program.

On Nov. 16, Ottawa’s immigration account advertised abroad for carpenters, plumbers and machinists. This year, 61,000 factory jobs are gone and 13.7% of young Canadians can’t find work. Some trades really are short of people: construction unemployment is under 4%. Train our own first.

The fix

  1. 01Canadians first for jobs. No new work permits while youth unemployment is in double digits.Our position
  2. 02Retrain laid-off factory workers and young Canadians for the trades before recruiting abroad.Our position

Sources: Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada, @CitImmCanada on X, Nov. 16, 2026 (skilled trades recruitment post); BuildForce Canada, from the Statistics Canada Labour Force Survey, September 2026 (construction unemployment 3.8%); Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, October 2026 (released Nov. 6, 2026: unemployment 6.7%, highest in six months; youth 15–24 unemployment 13.7%; 2026 job losses about 46,000), table 14-10-0287-01; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, nonfarm payrolls (+861,000, December 2025 to October 2026), via Dalhousie University Agri-Food Analytics Lab. The U.S. counts payroll jobs; Canada counts employed people, including the self-employed. Employment and Social Development Canada, refusal to process low-wage LMIAs in census metropolitan areas with unemployment of 6% or higher (30 of 41 CMAs, Oct. 9, 2026 to Jan. 7, 2027; areas outside CMAs not covered); Statistics Canada population estimates for July 1, 2026 (1,496,248 work permit holders); Plant by plant: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, June 2026 (manufacturing employment down 61,000, or 3.2%, from its January 2025 peak, “coinciding with a period of tariff-related uncertainty”); Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, August 2026 (Quebec employment down 54,000, or 1.2%, from August 2025, the only province with a year-over-year decline); BC Council of Forest Industries via The Canadian Press, July 2026 (about 15,000 forest jobs since 2022, 21 mill closures since 2023); CBS/AP and Canadian Press (Stellantis Brampton, about 3,000 workers, Oct. 2025); Algoma Steel and BNN Bloomberg (about 1,000, March 2026); Unifor via BNN Bloomberg (GM Oshawa, about 1,000, January 2026); Canfor (Vanderhoof and Fort St. John, 500); The Hub (Stelco, up to 500, Oct. 2026); CKTB News (Stanpac, about 350 of 550, Nov. 2026); The Canadian Press (Canfor Northwood, 300, July 2026); Unifor (PACCAR, 300); Unifor (Crown Royal, 200+); IRCC, 2026 Annual Report to Parliament on Immigration (2025: 743,770 work permits took effect, 580,125 under the International Mobility Program, which needs no Labour Market Impact Assessment, and 166,790 under the Temporary Foreign Worker Program).; Canada–China agreement, Jan. 2026, via Reuters and AP (up to 49,000 Chinese EVs a year at 6.1%, rising to about 70,000 over five years; previous tariff 100%); more than 80% of Canadian-built vehicles exported, 92% of those to the U.S. (≈74% of production); Ontario Premier Doug Ford statement, Jan. 2026

Business and trade · Built to keep you small

Approved. Cancelled.
Bought with your money.

$34B
what Trans Mountain cost taxpayers. Kinder Morgan walked away in 2018. Ottawa bought it for $4.5B and finished it at more than six times the 2016 estimate.
$1,500
per taxpayer, for one pipeline a private company had planned to build with its own money.
2Export pipelines killed after years of review: Northern Gateway (2016) and Energy East (2017)
14×Higher excise on small Canadian distillers than on U.S. ones. Big and small pay the same rate per litre
$500B+A year in goods and services crossing provincial borders, still tangled in provincial red tape

It’s not all Trump. The U.S. has charged duties on Canadian lumber since 1982. It’s about 35% today, and two trade deals never fixed it. On July 1, 2026, the U.S. declined to renew CUSMA, so the deal now gets reviewed every year until 2036. Would you build a factory here, not knowing the rules ten years out?

The result: we fell behind America.

14%How far output per Canadian has fallen behind America’s since 2015.
26%How far Canada’s productivity has fallen behind America’s since the late 1990s.
10%How far income per Canadian has fallen behind America’s since the late 1990s.

And who wins? The few companies that are already big.

96%
BanksRBC, TD, Scotiabank, BMO, CIBC, National

Of all banking assets in Canada sit with six banks.

90%
PhonesRogers, Bell, Telus

Of mobile revenue. The “cheap” brands are theirs too: Fido, Chatr, Virgin Plus, Lucky Mobile, Koodo, Public Mobile.

Up to 78%
AirlinesAir Canada, WestJet

Of domestic passengers at major airports. They’ve mostly split the country: Air Canada in the east, WestJet in the west.

5
GroceriesLoblaw, Sobeys, Metro, Costco, Walmart

Where most Canadians buy their food. The biggest grocers’ margins on food were rising even before the pandemic.

Hard rules don’t hurt the giants. They can afford the lawyers. They hurt whoever might have competed with them.

What we know: a company can spend a decade following every rule, win approval, and still lose it all to a court, a rule change or the next government. Both parties have done it. So investors build somewhere else, and Ottawa ends up building it with your money.

What we’re not saying: that every cancelled project should have been built. Courts, Indigenous consultation and oil prices killed projects too, and economists expect Trans Mountain to turn a profit over 20 years. The problem is the risk, not any one pipeline.

The fix

  1. 01Decide once. An approved project can’t be cancelled by the next government without paying for it.Our position
  2. 02One Canadian market. If it’s legal to sell in one province, it’s legal in all ten.Our position
  3. 03Lower excise for small producers, the way beer already works here and craft spirits work in the U.S.Canadian Craft Distillers Alliance
  4. 04Let new competitors in. Banks, phone carriers, airlines, grocers: if they’ll charge less, make it easy to open here.Competition Bureau, grocery market study (2023)

Sources: Banks: International Monetary Fund, Canada Financial Sector Assessment, 2025 (six domestic systemically important banks hold 96% of banking-sector assets). Phones: CRTC Communications Market Report data, 2023 (Bell, Rogers and Telus, with their flanker brands, 89.5% of retail mobile revenue). Airlines: Competition Bureau, Cleared for take-off, June 2025 (56% to 78% of domestic passengers at major airports; east–west split). Groceries: Competition Bureau, grocery market study, 2023. Trans Mountain Corp. and federal reporting via CTV News and The Logic (purchase $4.5B in 2018; final cost about $34B; 2016 estimate $7.4B; profit estimate $4.2B–$8.6B over 20 years, Trevor Tombe, University of Calgary); per taxpayer = $34B ÷ 22.57 million people who owed income tax in 2024 (Canada Revenue Agency); CBC and Reuters (Energy East cancelled Oct. 5, 2017, after the National Energy Board added upstream and downstream emissions to its review); National Post (Northern Gateway approved 2014, quashed by the Federal Court of Appeal and rejected by the federal government in 2016); Canadian Craft Distillers Alliance, April 2026 (excise up to 14× U.S. rates); Government of Canada, Advancing internal trade (over $500B a year, almost 20% of GDP); CFIB, State of Internal Trade 2026; Global Affairs Canada, softwood lumber (combined duties 24.75% plus a 10% U.S. tariff, October 2026); Blakes and White & Case, CUSMA joint review, July 1, 2026; Statistics Canada, Measuring Canada’s economic performance relative to the United States, March 25, 2026 (index, Canada/U.S., 1997 Q1 = 100: real GDP per capita 100.3 in 2015 Q1, 86.4 in 2025 Q3; labour productivity down 26% and real GNI per capita down 10% since the late 1990s); Competition Bureau, Retail grocery market study, June 2023; carrier brand ownership per company filings as summarized by iPhone in Canada, 2026.

Your Canada · 2026

Same work. Less life.

Forget Ottawa’s numbers for a second. This is what living here costs now.

2.35M

Food bank visits in one month

March 2026. More than double 2019. One in three is a child. Nearly one in five has a job.

5.8M

Adults with no family doctor

Or nurse practitioner. Of people looking for one, 45% have searched for over a year. In 2015 it was 31%.

14+hrs

In the ER, for 1 in 10 patients

1.5 million people in 2024–25. Up 28% since 2018–19. If you’re admitted, 1 in 10 wait two days for a bed.

53%

Of a typical household’s income

Before tax, just to carry the cost of owning a typical home. Q2 2026.

+101%

Real home prices, 2005 → 2025

The biggest jump of any peer country. US +30%. Germany +21%. UK +13%.

20%+

Unemployment for 15–19-year-olds

Mid-2026. All youth, 15–24: 13.7% in October.

A normal job used to cover a normal life. Then Ottawa added millions of people.
It never made room for them.

And now Ottawa wants foreign buyers back in. Budget 2026 keeps the ban on existing homes until 2029, but opens new homes to non-Canadians: the condos and starter homes first-time buyers can actually reach. It’s a proposal, not law yet.

The fix

  1. 01Canadians first. Hold population growth near zero until homes, doctors and ERs catch up.Our position
  2. 02Every province gets a real plan to stop ER closures.Ontario’s Auditor General found it had none, 2023
  3. 03Back to 2015’s ratio of administrators to private-sector jobs. About 180,000 fewer.Economist Jason Childs, Fraser Institute, 2026

Sources: Food Banks Canada, HungerCount 2026 (Oct 21, 2026); OurCare National Survey with the Canadian Medical Association (Feb 2026); Angus Reid Institute, health care access survey (Feb 5, 2026); Canadian Institute for Health Information, ED wait times report, June 25, 2026; RBC Economics, Housing affordability, Sept 28, 2026 (52.8%, Q2 2026); CMHC, Canada’s house prices vs peer countries (real prices 2005–2025); Centre for the Study of Living Standards, The Weakest Link, Sept 2026 (15–19 unemployment); Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, Oct 2026 (youth 13.7%); Government of Canada, Budget 2026, Nov. 5, 2026 (Prohibition on the Purchase of Residential Property by Non-Canadians Act extended to Jan. 1, 2029, with a proposed exemption for new residential property).

2015 → 2025 · The Trudeau decade, carried on by Carney

Trudeau · 2015–25
Carney · 2025–

Ten years. Here’s the bill.

What it was when they took over. What it is now. Read it slowly.

Federal debtAccumulated deficit, 2014–15 → 2024–25
$612B
→
$1.27T
Doubled
Interest on that debtPer year · money that buys nothing
~$26B
→
$53.7B
Doubled
The deficitPromised balanced by 2019 · 10 deficits in a row instead
$0
→
$36B
Broken
Federal public serviceGrew 43% while the population grew 16%
257,034
→
367,772
Bloated
Government’s share of all jobsFederal, provincial and local · 950,000 jobs added 2015–2024, about 30% of all new jobsMore than the UK, Australia, the US or Germany. OECD, 2021.
19.7%
→
21.8%
1 in 5
Federal payrollSalaries, bonuses, pensions and benefits, per year
$39.6B
→
$71.4B
+80%
Outside consultants and contractorsPer year · promised to cut them in 2015
$8.3B
→
$19.5B
Broken
PopulationNo housing, doctors or roads to match · 2023 alone: +3.2%, fastest since 1957, 98% from immigration
35.7M
→
41.7M
+6 million
Average home priceNational, CREA
$443K
→
~$690K
+56%
Wait for surgeryFrom GP referral to treatment
18.3 wks
→
28.6 wks
Worse
Food bank visits, one monthMarch 2019 → March 2026
~1.09M
→
2.35M
Record
Held to accountAfter courts ruled the 2022 Emergencies Act use unlawful · Federal Court 2024, upheld 2026
2 rulings
→
0
Nobody
4.6MCanadians on a government payroll. More than 1 in 5 workers.
+80%Federal payroll in ten years: $39.6B to $71.4B a year.
$237BRoads, pipes, bridges and water systems rated poor or very poor.

More people. More pay. Same crumbling roads.

Your tax bill · and what it buys

$47,500 in tax collected for every taxpayer, every year. And last place for seeing a doctor.

$3,960Every month, per taxpayer. Every level of government, every kind of tax: income, sales, property, payroll and business.
$1.07TTaken in by every government in 2024, divided by the 22.57 million people who paid income tax.
26%Of Canadians got in to see a doctor the same or next day last time they were sick. Last of 10 rich countries. It was 46% in 2016.
June 9
You work this long just to pay your taxes.
June 25
Count what they borrow, too. 16 more days of your year, put on credit. You pay it back later, with interest.

Same taxes. Half the doctor.

CountryYou pay · tax, % of GDPYou get · doctor same or next day
Netherlands38.5%54%
Germany38.0%51%
United Kingdom34.4%47%
United States25.6%43%
Canada34.9%26%

The UK pays almost exactly what we do and gets nearly twice the access. Americans pay nine points less and still get in faster. The Dutch pay a bit more and get double. It isn’t how much you pay. It’s what you get back. Canada is last.

New leader, more spending · Parliamentary Budget Officer, Nov. 17, 2026

His budget

$331.6 billion in new spending. Three plans in one year.

$14,700
Per taxpayerAcross all three plans

New measures in Budget 2025, the spring 2026 update and Budget 2026, divided by 22.57 million taxpayers.

60%
Goes to running governmentNot the building he promised

“This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more,” the budget officer said.

96%
Of the windfall, spentBudget 2026

More tax money came in than expected. Ottawa spent 96% of it instead of shrinking the deficit.

The borrowing they don’t count · Parliamentary Budget Officer, Nov. 2026

His budget

They say $289 billion. They’re borrowing $765 billion.

$289B
The deficits they report over the next five years.
$765B
What they’re actually borrowing. About $33,900 per taxpayer.
$260B
Loans and investments in Crown corporations2026–27 to 2030–31

None of it counts in the deficit. The budget lumps it into one line, so Parliament can’t tell which Crown corporations get it or how much risk you’re carrying.

$135.8B
Called “investment.” The world wouldn’t.2026–27 to 2030–31

Tax breaks, housing tax measures, business R&D support and battery-plant subsidies. Ottawa files them as capital, and under its own rules, capital is what it’s allowed to borrow for. Under the international standard, they’re day-to-day spending. Count them that way and the “operating budget” stays in deficit every year to 2030–31. About $6,000 per taxpayer.

$113B
Alto high-speed rail, Toronto to Quebec CityBudget officer, Oct. 2026

Ottawa says $60 to $90 billion. Its own budget officer says $75 to $113 billion, and puts a 1-in-40 chance on $243 billion or more.

0
Dollar limits on borrowingOttawa’s own fiscal rules

Neither of the government’s fiscal anchors caps how much it borrows. It can “meet its targets” while borrowing three-quarters of a trillion dollars.

5%
NATO defence targetPromised, not counted

The extra spending to reach it isn’t in the long-term projections. If it’s borrowed, the real debt is higher than what you’re being shown.

At the House of Commons finance committee, an MP walked the budget officer through every one of these. Her answer, again and again: “Correct.”

What we’re not saying: that it’s all spending. Loans to Crown corporations are supposed to be paid back, and some of the borrowing builds real things.

What we are saying: if it doesn’t count in the deficit, it should still be in front of Parliament, line by line. Right now it isn’t.

The top of the pay scale · From Ottawa’s own orders in council

Three new agencies. Bosses who can out-earn the Prime Minister.

In 2025 Ottawa created a Major Projects Office, a Defence Investment Agency and Build Canada Homes. Their heads got some of the biggest pay ranges in government.

$679K
Top of the pay range for the heads of the Major Projects Office and the Defence Investment Agency. Before a bonus of up to 33%.
$420K
About what the Prime Minister makes.
$101,800
Room to climb, same jobMajor Projects Office · Defence Investment Agency

Their range starts at $577,300 and tops out at $679,100. Anyone rated “succeeded” or better gets a raise up the range every year, plus bonus pay. Almost everyone is rated “succeeded.”

$469,100
Build Canada Homes CEO, top of rangeFrom $398,800 · five-year term

For an agency created in September 2025. The budget officer expects it to add about 26,000 homes over five years. Housing starts in the first nine months of 2026 were down 4%, and Budget 2026 dropped the promise to double home building.

$67,800
Raise at the top deputy minister level since 2018DM-4 maximum: $352,800 → $420,600

That raise alone is more than a typical Canadian living alone takes home in a whole year: $41,000. Up to 39% more in bonuses.

95 of 96
Deputy ministers who got performance pay2023–24 · Privy Council Office

Only one got none. Crown corporation CEOs: 40 of 40. Federal executives: 97.4%. A pay system where almost nobody loses.

1
Top job advertised to the publicSince March 2025

More than 100 Governor in Council appointments since then. One was posted openly: the budget officer. The rest were picked.

+52%
Federal executivesCore public service, 2015 → 2025

4,958 to 7,555. Ottawa’s own HR chief found 421 assistant deputy ministers for 355 permanent jobs at that level.

What we’re not saying: that they’re overpaid next to the private sector. Farrell made $7.8 million at TransAlta in 2021. And in percentage terms, deputy ministers’ raises roughly kept pace with prices.

What we are saying: a government that promised 40,000 fewer jobs keeps adding jobs at the top, and new agencies with new top salaries.

Trudeau · 2015–25
Carney · 2025–

New leader. Same cabinet.
Same direction.

We’re not telling you which jersey to wear. We’re telling you what a decade of results looks like, and that the bill lands on you and your kids either way. Anyone who wants your vote answers for every line on this page first. Until then: no thank you.

13 of 28. Carney’s ministers who sat in Trudeau’s cabinet. His first full cabinet, May 2025.

FPC

François-Philippe Champagne

TrudeauIndustry. Foreign Affairs.

CarneyFinance. He wrote Budget 2026.

DL

Dominic LeBlanc

TrudeauFinance. Public Safety.

CarneyCanada–U.S. trade, the provinces.

MJ

Mélanie Joly

TrudeauForeign Affairs.

CarneyIndustry.

AA

Anita Anand

TrudeauDefence. Treasury Board.

CarneyForeign Affairs.

SF

Sean Fraser

TrudeauImmigration, 2021–23. Then Housing.

CarneyJustice.

Also at the table, May 2025: Chrystia Freeland, Steven Guilbeault, Steven MacKinnon, David McGuinty, Gary Anandasangaree, Patty Hajdu.

GR

And the new face

179%

Gregor Robertson, federal housing minister

How much Metro Vancouver home prices rose while he was mayor, 2008 to 2018. In May 2025, Carney put him in charge of housing for the whole country. Asked if prices need to come down, he said no.

The fix

  1. 01Ottawa grades its own homework. Let the watchdog we already pay for check every budget promise. No new office.The Parliamentary Budget Officer asked for this, Nov 2025
  2. 02Make the consultant cut real. Ottawa promised 20% less. Spending still hit a record $26.1B.Budget 2025; PIPSC
  3. 03Hold them to it: 40,000 fewer federal positions by 2028–29.Ottawa’s own Budget 2025 target
  4. 04Not one more dollar in tax until the service gets better.Our position
  5. 05Put the deficit limit in law, not in a speech. Ottawa promised no more than $40.1B and ran $61.9B.Our position · Fall Economic Statement 2024
  6. 06Send every taxpayer a receipt: what you paid, and where it went.The UK has done it since 2014, for about 24 million taxpayers
  7. 07No new agency head paid more than the Prime Minister. Fewer executives before fewer front-line workers.Our position

Sources: Fraser Institute, Tax Freedom Day 2026 (June 9; the average household of two or more pays $72,539 in total tax on $166,790 of income, 43.5%; Balanced Budget Tax Freedom Day June 25); Finance Canada, Fiscal Reference Tables 2025; Fraser Institute (deficits, debt interest); Treasury Board Secretariat, Population of the Federal Public Service (2025); Parliamentary Budget Officer and Public Accounts (payroll); Fraser Institute, public-sector employment (2025); Federation of Canadian Municipalities and Statistics Canada, Core Public Infrastructure Survey (infrastructure); Public Accounts via The Canadian Press, Nov 2025 (external services); Statistics Canada (population, July 2025); CREA annual averages; Fraser Institute, Waiting Your Turn (2015, 2025); Food Banks Canada, HungerCount 2025. Rounded; Federal Court, 2024 FC 42, and Federal Court of Appeal, 2026 FCA 6 (Emergencies Act); Statistics Canada, population estimates, March 27, 2024 (2023 growth); IRCC, 2026–2028 Immigration Levels Plan (temporary resident arrivals cut from 673,650 to 385,000); OECD, Government at a Glance 2023 country notes (general government employment, 2021: Canada, France, UK, Germany, OECD average); Per Capita citing OECD (Australia, 2023); OECD, Government at a Glance 2025 (general government employment, 2023) and OECD, Size and Composition of Public Employment, 2024 (US, 2021); Norwegian Petroleum Directorate / NBIM (Government Pension Fund Global, about NOK 21,300 billion at end of 2025); MarketScreener, Jan 2026 (fund finances nearly 20% of Norway’s budget). Tax: Statistics Canada, Consolidated Canadian Government Finance Statistics, 2024 ($1,072.1B in taxes and social contributions collected by all governments plus the Canada and Quebec Pension Plans; includes business taxes); Canada Revenue Agency, 2024 tax year (22,569,830 people who owed income tax; $1,072.1B ÷ 22.57M ≈ $47,500, or ≈ $3,960 a month); OECD, Revenue Statistics 2025 (tax-to-GDP, 2024 provisional: Netherlands 38.5%, Germany 38.0%, Canada 34.9%, United Kingdom 34.4%, United States 25.6%); Commonwealth Fund, International Health Policy Survey 2023, via CIHI (same- or next-day appointment the last time sick: Netherlands 54%, Germany 51%, UK 47%, US 43%, Canada 26%, last of 10; Canada 46% in 2016). Fixes: Finance Canada, Fall Economic Statement 2024 (2023–24 deficit of $61.9B against a pledged cap of $40.1B); HM Revenue and Customs, Annual Tax Summary (first sent to about 24 million UK taxpayers in November 2014).; Parliamentary Budget Officer, Review of Budget 2026, Nov. 17, 2026 (new measures in Budget 2025, the Spring Economic Update 2026 and Budget 2026 total $331.6B; most go to day-to-day operations; 96% of new fiscal room used); The Canadian Press, Nov. 17, 2026 (about 60% for day-to-day operations); $331.6B ÷ 22.57M taxpayers (CRA, 2024) ≈ $14,700; Parliamentary Budget Officer, PBO Assessment of Budget 2026: Fiscal Anchors and Fiscal Sustainability, and Economic and Fiscal Track, Nov. 17, 2026 (financial requirement $764.7B vs cumulative deficits $288.7B over 2026–27 to 2030–31; net lending and investment in enterprise Crown corporations $260.2B; neither anchor limits borrowing); PBO news release, Nov. 17, 2026 (staffing figures leave out Crown corporations); The Canadian Press, Nov. 17, 2026 (Crown corporation loans presented as a single line item); House of Commons Standing Committee on Finance, testimony of the Parliamentary Budget Officer, Nov. 2026 (Crown corporation reporting, NATO 5% not in long-term projections, public service figures exclude Crown corporations and contracting); The Hub, Oct. 23, 2026 (OGGO testimony: $141B in Crown loans carries write-off risk); $765B ÷ 22.57M taxpayers (CRA, 2024) ≈ $33,900; CBC News, May 2025 (13 of 28 ministers in Carney’s post-election cabinet served in Trudeau’s cabinet); Prime Minister’s Office, cabinet of May 13, 2025 (Champagne, Finance and National Revenue; LeBlanc, Canada–U.S. Trade and Intergovernmental Affairs; Joly, Industry; Anand, Foreign Affairs; Fraser, Justice); The Canadian Press, Nov. 2026 (Champagne tabled Budget 2026 as finance minister); Am800/The Canadian Press, May 13, 2025 (Freeland, Guilbeault, MacKinnon among returning Trudeau-era ministers); CBC News, May 2025 (McGuinty at Defence, Anandasangaree at Public Safety); CMHC via Mortgage Professional Australia/MPA, May 2025 (average single-family and semi-detached prices in Metro Vancouver up 179% during Robertson’s 2008–2018 mayoralty); Global News, May 14, 2025 (“Should home prices go down? ‘No,’ says Canada’s new housing minister”); The Canadian Press, Nov. 2026 (Robertson still housing minister); Parliamentary Budget Officer, PBO Assessment of Budget 2026: Fiscal Anchors and Fiscal Sustainability, Nov. 17, 2026 (capital-focused tax incentives, housing tax measures, private-sector R&D support and battery manufacturing support total $135.8B over 2026–27 to 2030–31, 37% of capital investments; not capital formation under the System of National Accounts; treated as operating, the operating balance stays in deficit every year to 2030–31); House of Commons Standing Committee on Finance, PBO testimony, Nov. 2026 ($135 billion); $135.8B ÷ 22.57M taxpayers (CRA, 2024) ≈ $6,000; Orders in council via The Canadian Press, Oct. 10, 2025 (Farrell, Major Projects Office, and Guzman, Defence Investment Agency: $577,300 to $679,100, not including performance pay; maximum performance award for Crown corporation CEO 8 is 33%; the Prime Minister makes nearly $420,000); Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada, committee briefing, March 2026 (Bailão, Build Canada Homes CEO, $398,800 to $469,100, effective Sept. 29, 2025, five-year term); Privy Council Office, salary ranges for the EX and DM groups (DM 4: $299,900–$352,800 in 2018–19; $357,600–$420,600 in 2025–26; maximum performance award 39%); Statistics Canada, Canadian Income Survey 2024, April 29, 2026 (median after-tax income of unattached individuals $41,000); Treasury Board Secretariat, Population of the federal public service by executive level (core public administration executives 4,958 in 2015, 7,555 in 2025); National Post, Aug. 1, 2025, Chief Human Resources Officer memo (421 assistant deputy ministers, 355 permanent positions); CBC News, Sept. 2025 (Farrell earned $7.8M at TransAlta in 2021); Privy Council Office, Results for the 2023-24 Performance Cycle (deputy ministers: 96, of whom 1 received no at-risk pay; Crown corporation CEOs: 40, none without performance pay); Privy Council Office, Performance Awards for Deputy Ministers, Associate Deputy Ministers and GX (in-range increase for ratings of Succeeded– and above); Treasury Board Secretariat, Results of the Performance Management Program for Executives 2023-2024 (7,960 executives, 97.4%, earned performance pay); HR Reporter, citing CBC News, 2026 (one Governor in Council role, the parliamentary budget officer, publicly advertised since March 2025; more than 100 appointments made); Parliamentary Budget Officer, Build Canada Homes, 2025 (about 26,000 additional units over five years); CMHC data via Fraser Institute, Nov. 2026 (170,964 starts in the first nine months of 2026, down 4% from 2025); The Canadian Press, Nov. 10, 2026 (Budget 2026 omits the pledge to double home building; new target to triple non-market starts); Parliamentary Budget Officer, Alto high-speed rail cost analysis, Oct. 1, 2026 ($75B to $113B vs. Ottawa’s $60B to $90B; 1-in-40 probability of $243B or more)

The ledger

They spend it like it’s theirs. It’s yours.

Every week, another billion-dollar announcement. Every new dollar is borrowed, and you’re paying the interest. "Spent in Canada" doesn’t mean spent well. So here’s what each one really is, what they promised, and the date we check.

Every government, all in · federal, provincial and local · 2024

$50,400

What every level of government spent for each person who pays income tax, in one year. Here’s where yours went.

Social protectionPensions, EI, child benefits, welfare
~$12,540
HealthHospitals, doctors, drugs
~$11,940
Schools, defence, police, roads and the restEverything else every government does
~$16,510
Running governmentDepartments, admin, offices
~$3,090
Interest on government debtBuys nothing
~$4,550
Environmental protection
~$1,750

$4,550 of yours went to interest. It buys nothing. $3,040 of what they spent was borrowed. Your kids pay that back.

Statistics Canada, Consolidated Canadian Government Finance Statistics, 2024: $1,137.1B spent by all governments combined (excluding the Canada and Quebec Pension Plans), $68.5B deficit. Divided by the 22.57 million people who owed income tax in 2024 (Canada Revenue Agency). Health is 23.7% of spending as Statistics Canada reports it; “schools, defence, police, roads and the rest” is what remains after the categories shown. Rounded.

Per taxpayer · what it costs each person who pays income tax

$56,300Your share of the federal debt
$26,100Your share of what Ottawa spends, 2026–27
$2,760Borrowed this year · $62.3B deficit, Budget 2026
$3,800Interest on the debt, every year by 2030–31
$6,960Defence, every year by 2030–31
$1,180Ukraine, committed since 2022
$440Foreign aid, every year · all of it borrowed
$155Asylum system, every year

Each total is divided by the 22.57 million people who owed income tax in 2024 (Canada Revenue Agency, 2024 tax year), not by everyone. Kids, and people who paid no income tax, are left out. Rounded. Debt: federal accumulated deficit of about $1.27 trillion (2024–25). Spending: about $589B (2026–27). Deficit: Budget 2026’s $62.3B for 2026–27. Interest: about $86B a year by 2030–31. Defence: about $157B a year by 2030–31. Ukraine: $26.7B committed since 2022, part of it loans. Foreign aid: $9.9B in official development assistance (2024–25). Asylum: about $3.5B a year. While Ottawa runs a deficit, every new dollar, at home or abroad, is borrowed.

Foreign aid · Where your money goes

Justin Trudeau, 2015–2025

Foreign aid nearly doubled.
Fix our own house first.

1.9×
Global Affairs aid. $3.44 billion in 2014–15. $6.38 billion in 2024–25.
$2.4B
of “foreign aid” spent here, on asylum claimants’ health care, food and shelter. 2024–25.
95%Of Ottawa’s development aid has to include a gender goal. That’s the rule
$3.5BA year in aid the Auditor General couldn’t link to results for women and girls
2 of 3Of its own spending targets Ottawa missed

Then and now · Global Affairs Canada aid spending

All foreign aidGlobal Affairs Canada1.9×
$3.44B2014–15 · $4.42B today$6.38B2024–25
Aid with a gender requirementA gender goal attached to a project about something else3.6×
$874M2014–15 · $1.12B today$3.16B2024–25
Aid that’s mainly about genderThe project exists for gender13×
$48M2014–15 · $61M today$646M2024–25
Aid that’s mainly about climateGlobal Affairs’ own climate coding15×
$78M2014–15 · $100M today$1.18B2024–25

Cream: 2014–15. Red: 2024–25. White line: 2014–15 in today’s dollars (prices +28.5%). Even after inflation, aid mainly about gender is up 10.5 times, and climate almost 12 times.

Project by project · biggest first

$100M
African Development Bank2022

For gender-oriented small farm and food businesses in Africa.

$48M
IPPF “EmpowHER”Global

Sexual and reproductive health, run by the International Planned Parenthood Federation.

$30M
LGBTQ2I programGlobal

Canada’s LGBTQ2I international assistance program, including a seven-year, $16.7M fund.

$25.2M
Urgent Action Fund-Africa2025 to 2030

Women’s voice and leadership in crisis and conflict zones.

$16M
Journalists for Human Rights2025 to 2028

“Amplifying Voices of Women and Girls.”

$15.5M
Kenya2022 to 2027

Women- and youth-run farm and fishing businesses, partly spent on changing “social norms.”

$6M
Women’s land and housingAngola, Kenya, South Africa, Uganda

Women’s rights to land, housing and livelihoods.

$449K
West Africa2023 to 2026

Human rights and wellbeing of LGBTQ2I women and girls.

The climate money · spent abroad in 2024–25, plus this week

$560M
Brazil-led rainforest fundPledged Nov. 15, 2026

Up to $560 million over four years, announced in Manila. It counts toward Ottawa’s goal of over $13 billion in climate money for other countries by 2031.

$240M
Latin America and the CaribbeanClimate resilience accelerator

One year of a Canadian climate fund for the region.

$8.7B
Climate money sent abroad2015 to 2022 · Ottawa’s own count

All sources combined. The new goal: over $13 billion by 2031.

$200M
India, Indonesia, South Africa, the PhilippinesCoal transition program

Helping other countries close their coal plants.

$150M
AsiaClimate and nature fund

For private companies.

$150M
Global biodiversity fundAsia, Africa, the Americas

Nature protection, worldwide.

$4.7M
Tanzania2024–25

“Feminist Entrepreneurs Growing Green Economies.” That’s the real name.

$13.4 billion a year in aid. That’s almost a quarter of what Ottawa sends every province for health care, combined ($57.4 billion). You don’t fix your neighbour’s house before your own.

What we’re not saying: this is a slice of Canada’s $13.4 billion in aid. The climate money is part of Ottawa’s goal of over $13 billion in climate finance for developing countries by 2031. Supporters call these cheap, targeted poverty and rights programs, and the OECD ranked Canada first for aid focused on gender.

What we are saying: a rule sends 95% of development aid through a gender lens, and the government’s own auditor couldn’t show it improved anything.

The fix

  1. 01Measure results, not intentions. Every aid project reports what it actually changed.Auditor General, 2023
  2. 02Drop the 95% gender quota. Pick projects on results.Our position
  3. 03Our own house first. No new aid money while Ottawa borrows to pay for it and Canadians wait half a year for treatment.Our position
  4. 04No more paying other countries to close their coal plants while ours pay the carbon bills.Our position

Sources: Global Affairs Canada, Report to Parliament on International Assistance 2024–25 (gender equality $261M; sexual and reproductive health and rights $762M); Global Affairs Canada, Statistical Report on International Assistance 2024–25 (total $13.36B); Global Affairs Canada, Minister of International Development briefing book, May 2025 (95% of bilateral development aid integrates gender equality, 15% as the main goal); Auditor General of Canada, Report 4, International Assistance in Support of Gender Equality, 2023 (about $3.5B a year; 2 of 3 commitments missed; OECD ranking); Global Affairs Canada Project Browser and Government of Canada grants records (project amounts; Kenya: Leveraging Equality for Gender-Just Economic Development, MEDA, $15,498,687, 2022–2027); IPPF (EmpowHER, CAD $48M). Global Affairs Canada, Historical Project Data Sets, 2014–15 (Global Affairs only, $3.44B; gender coded specific $47.8M, integrated $873.8M) and 2024–25 (all departments, $13.36B; Global Affairs $6.38B; gender specific $645.5M, integrated $3.16B; refugees and asylum seekers in Canada: Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada $1.96B and provincial governments $450M). Climate as the main goal (OECD climate markers): $77.7M in 2014–15, $1.18B in 2024–25 at Global Affairs; 2024–25 climate projects by title: climate resilience accelerator $240M, Accelerating Coal Transition program $200M, climate and nature fund for the private sector in Asia $150M, Global biodiversity framework fund $150M, Feminist Entrepreneurs Growing Green Economies $4.7M. Our totals from the government’s files. Inflation toggle: Statistics Canada CPI, annual averages (125.2 in 2014, 160.9 in 2024). $1.02B ÷ 22.57M taxpayers (CRA, 2024) ≈ $45. Project totals are multi-year.; Prime Minister’s Office, Nov. 15, 2026 (up to $560M over four years to the Tropical Forest Forever Facility; climate finance goal of over $13B by 2031); Environment and Climate Change Canada, Canada’s international climate finance (more than $8.7 billion in climate finance from 2015 to 2022, all sources)

Your kids don’t pay tax yet. They inherit the $1.27 trillion.

$53.7B a year in interest. Almost as much as Ottawa sends every province for health care, combined. See where the big money goes ↓

Where the big money goes · 2026–27

ProgramWhat it isPer yearWhat we get, and the catchCheck
Seniors (OAS and GIS)
Spent here
$88.8B
The biggest single program, about one in every six federal dollars. Paid to seniors regardless of need above modest thresholds.
~$3,930 per taxpayer
Health transfer to provinces
Spent here
$57.4B
Up 5% this year, guaranteed by law. Meanwhile the median wait from referral to treatment is 28.6 weeks.
~$2,540 per taxpayer. Are waits falling?
Interest on the debt
Lost
$53.7B
Buys nothing. Already about the size of the entire health transfer, and climbing.
~$2,380 per taxpayer
Employment Insurance
Spent here
$31.9B
Income support for people out of work, funded by payroll premiums.
~$1,410 per taxpayer
Canada Child Benefit
Spent here
$31.2B
Monthly payments to families with kids, based on income.
~$1,380 per taxpayer
Dental care plan
Spent here
$4.7B
Covers about 6.9 million people. The Auditor General found benefits ran $1.1B over budget in the first two years, with a $2.4B shortfall projected to 2031–32.
Who covers the shortfall
Health care for asylum claimants (IFHP)
Spent here
~$1.1B
Up from $211M in 2020–21 to $896M in 2024–25, for 623,000 people. Projected at $1.5B a year by 2029–30. Over 300,000 claims are waiting for a decision, most for over a year.
Backlog cleared, co-pays working
Housing for asylum claimants
Spent here
$2B+
Spent since 2017 on hotels, shelters and payments to provinces and cities for interim housing. Another $1.1B was budgeted over three years to 2026–27, when the program is set to end.
Cost per claimant, per year
Newcomer settlement services
Spent here
$936M
Language classes, job help and orientation, mostly for permanent residents, plus first-weeks support for government-assisted refugees. Down from about $1.2B in 2024–25.
Do newcomers find work faster?
Immigration department, all in
Spent here
$4.4B
Everything Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada plans to spend in 2026–27, down from $6.05B forecast for 2025–26 as levels and programs are cut.
Is the backlog shrinking?
$26.7B to Ukraine. $32.5B in tariff relief. $25B for a wealth fund. Every announcement, sorted. See all 18 ↓

The announcements

AnnouncementWhat it isAmountWhat we were promisedCheck
Tariff relief for workers and firms
Spent here
$32.5B
Protect jobs and companies hit by U.S. tariffs.
Jobs saved, published by sector
Ontario steel and auto plan
Spent here
~$9B
Joint federal–Ontario support for tariff-hit industries.
Who got it, and what stayed open
Defence build-up
Spent here
~$157B/yr
About 4% of GDP by 2030–31.
Competed contracts, delivered on time
Toronto rental homes
Spent here
$2.7B
Over 3 years, 5,600+ rentals in 18 stalled projects. About $1.8B of it is CMHC construction loans, not grants. Separate from the $1.5B Toronto got to cut development charges.
Shovels in the ground, homes finished
One million home retrofits
Spent here
$2B
Over 8 years. Heat pump rebates for up to 820,000 homeowners ($2,000, or up to $10,000 below median income), approvals in 24 hours, $1,400+ a year in savings for oil, propane and electric heat. Check the math: 820,000 rebates at the $2,000 minimum is already $1.64B.
Homes done each year, and when the money runs out
Canada Strong Fund
Investment
$25B
A sovereign wealth fund investing alongside private companies.
Annual returns, in public
Cohere equity stake
Investment
$1.6B
Stay in Canada, 1,000+ jobs, $1.7B in Canadian compute by 2030.
2030
Telesat Arctic satellites
Contract
$2.3B
Secure Arctic communications for the Forces.
Service live in 2028
Churchill Falls and Gull Island hydro
Financing
Up to $10B
Federal backing announced Aug 17, 2026 for a ~$70B Quebec–Labrador hydro package. Pitched as “the largest clean energy investment in North American history.”
Built on time, and what Ottawa gets back
Ukraine, since 2022: total
Abroad
$26.7B
Everything committed since the 2022 invasion: military, loans, humanitarian, development, security and immigration assistance.
The split below
  ↳ Loans
At risk
~$13B
Mostly government-to-government loans. Payments are suspended until March 2027. The $5B G7 loan is meant to be repaid from profits on frozen Russian assets; the rest depends on Ukraine.
Do payments resume in 2027?
  ↳ Military aid
Abroad
$8.5B
Weapons, ammunition and vehicles. Part of it is spent in Canadian factories, like the 35 armoured vehicles built by General Dynamics Land Systems – Canada.
How much was built here
  ↳ Grants and everything else
Abroad
~$5B
Humanitarian, development, security, stabilization and immigration support. Not coming back.
Where it went, item by item
Brazil-led rainforest fund
Abroad
$560M
Up to $560M over four years to the Tropical Forests Forever Facility, announced Nov 15, 2026. Part of a pledge of more than $13B in climate finance to developing countries by 2031.
What it protected, and where
Aid to China, since 2015
Abroad
$109M
Still eligible under OECD rules because income per person is lower than ours, even though China’s economy is many times bigger. $645M since 2003.
Why we still send it
Palestinian aid
Abroad
$100M
$80M humanitarian, $20M security training.
Delivered to whom
Canada Investment Summit
Mostly private
"~$500B"
Touted as new investment unleashed. Most of it is bank lending and pension pledges, and some of it was announced before, like BDC’s $1B, which is part of an existing $6B program.
How much is actually new
COVID benefits written off
Lost
$4.5B
Overpayments and ineligible claims, never recovered.
Gone

Exhibit A · Paid either way

98% of federal bosses got a bonus.
Their departments missed nearly half their targets.

98%
of federal executives got a performance bonus. 7,987 of about 8,140, in 2024–25.
54%
of their departments’ own targets were actually met. Would you get a bonus for that?
$146MExecutive performance pay, 2024–25
3×As many federal staff paid $150K–$199K as four years ago · 4,191 → 12,971 · the cost of living rose 16%
$30.8MCanada Post bonuses · same year it lost ~$1.6B and got a $1B bailout
Executives paid a performance bonus7,987 of about 8,140 federal executives · 2024–25
98%
Department targets actually metOttawa’s own results data · 2024–25
54%

Meanwhile, at the top of the pay scale

Federal salaries of $150K–$199K4,191 in 2020–21 → 12,971 in 2024–25 · inflation +16%
+209%
Federal salaries of $250K–$299K62 → 220, same four years · inflation +16%
+255%

White line: what inflation alone would explain, over the same years (Statistics Canada CPI)

Look at the police brass

Peel Regional Police chief$299,196 in 2020 → $604,449 in 2025 · now the highest-paid police official in Canada · inflation +20%
+102%
Toronto Police chief$394,228 → $445,366 · 2024 to 2025 · inflation +2%
+13%
Toronto Police staff on the $100K list4,645 in 2015 → 6,114 in 2024 → 7,083 in 2025 · inflation +30%
+52%
Toronto Police budget$958M in 2015 → $1.43B in 2026 (net) · inflation +32%
+49%
OPP staff on the $100K list5,248 in 2022 → 5,329 → 5,825 → 7,698 in 2025 · inflation +9%
+47%
OPP budget$1.2B in 2020–21 → $1.89B in 2025–26 · inflation +20%
+57%

White line: what inflation alone would explain, over the same years (Statistics Canada CPI)

This isn’t one person. It’s the government’s own numbers, every executive and every department. Nearly all of them get performance pay. Barely half the targets get met. In two of the last five years, departments missed more than half.

Ottawa’s answer: its bonuses average about 11% of salary, less than the private sector’s. Ours: in the private sector, a team that misses half its targets doesn’t get one.

The fix

  1. 01No bonus in a year your department misses most of its targets.

Sources: Treasury Board Secretariat, Results of the Performance Management Program for Executives 2024–25 and Question Period notes; Government of Canada departmental results via The Canadian Press, Feb 2026; Treasury Board salary data tabled in Parliament, Dec 2025; Canadian Taxpayers Federation access-to-information records (Canada Post); Ontario Public Sector Salary Disclosure 2016–2025 (police chiefs and service totals); Statistics Canada CPI; Statistics Canada CPI, Table 18-10-0005-01, annual averages (2015: 126.6, 2020: 137.0, 2022: 151.2, 2024: 160.9, 2025: 164.2; 2026 year to date); Canada Revenue Agency, Individual Income Tax Return Statistics, 2024 tax year (22,569,830 taxable returns; $26.7B ÷ 22.57M ≈ $1,180, part of it loans).

Exhibit B · Who pays, who gets paid

You’re paying for a pension
you will never get.

87%
of government workers have a workplace pension. Almost all of them guaranteed for life.
20%
of private-sector workers do. That’s you, probably. The other 80% fund their own retirement, and help fund the government’s.
+22%More per hour, on average
1.4 yrsEarlier retirement
+4.8%More pay for the same job, even matched on age, education and experience
Government worker, averagePer hour, all levels of government · 2024
$40.83
Private-sector worker, averagePer hour · 2024
$33.35

And then the retirement

Has a workplace pensionGovernment workers
87%
Has a workplace pensionPrivate-sector workers
20%
Pension is defined-benefit (guaranteed)Government workers with a pension
92%
Pension is defined-benefit (guaranteed)Private-sector workers with a pension
41%

How many · the federal public service

Justin Trudeau, 2015–2025

Nine years before 2015: up 3%. Nine years since: up 43%.

249,932 in 2006. 257,034 in 2015. 367,772 by 2024. Canada grew about 16% over those last nine years.

250K2006283K2010257K20152020368K20242026BEFORE 2015TRUDEAU · CARNEY250K’06’10257K’15’20368K’24BEFORE 2015TRUDEAU · CARNEY

How much · what they cost you

Justin Trudeau, 2015–2025

Nine years before 2015: up 29%. Nine years since: up 80%.

$30.6 billion in 2006–07. $39.6 billion in 2015–16. $71.4 billion in 2024–25: about $3,160 per taxpayer, every year. 2015–16 in today’s dollars: $50.4 billion. Pay per worker kept pace with inflation. The rest is 111,000 more workers.

$30.6B2006–0710–11$39.6B15–1620–21$71.4B2024–25BEFORE 2015TRUDEAU · CARNEY2015–16 IN TODAY’S $ · $50.4B’06$39.6B’15$71.4B’24BEFORE 2015TRUDEAU · CARNEY2015–16 IN TODAY’S $ · $50.4B

Grey: before 2015. Red: Trudeau and Carney. These counts leave out Crown corporations entirely, and the outside contractors. Headcount is each March. Cost is pay, pensions, benefits and one-time payments, which make some years jump. It also covers soldiers and RCMP officers, who aren’t in the headcount. Federal only. Provinces and cities pay their own: see Exhibit C.

Where the money really goes

It’s not their raises. It’s how many, and the extras.

Government raises haven’t beaten private ones. The bill blew up anyway:

  • 950,000 more government jobs since 2015. 328,200 were administrators, not nurses or teachers.
  • 3× as many federal salaries of $150K–$199K
  • 98% of federal bosses got a bonus
  • 87% of government workers have a pension. Only 20% of private-sector workers do

You pay for their pension. Then you save for your own.

The fix

  1. 01No new hires above population growth.
  2. 02Publish total pay, pension included, for every role.
  3. 03New hires get the same kind of pension most Canadians have.

Sources: Treasury Board Secretariat, Population of the Federal Public Service, March 2006 to March 2026 (2006 to 2014 as reported by The Globe and Mail, July 2014, and the Montreal Economic Institute’s annex of the same Treasury Board table; Canadian population 35,606,734 in 2015 and 40,990,297 in 2024); Parliamentary Budget Officer, Federal Personnel Spending: Past and Future Trends, 2018, Figure A-2 (cash personnel spending, 2006–07 to 2014–15); Public Accounts of Canada, personnel spending by ministry, 2015–16 to 2024–25, as compiled by the Canadian Taxpayers Federation (matches PBO for overlapping years); Parliamentary Budget Officer, personnel expenditure analysis, Feb 2026 ($76.3B including other items). $71.4B ÷ 22.57M taxpayers (CRA, 2024) ≈ $3,160. Statistics Canada, Quality of Employment in Canada: Average earnings, 2024 (hourly wages, growth since 2006); Statistics Canada, Pension Plans in Canada and Labour Force Survey, 2023 (87.4% of public-sector and 20.4% of private-sector workers covered by a registered pension plan); Fraser Institute, Comparing Government and Private Sector Compensation in Canada, 2025 (wage premium, retirement age); Fraser Institute, Examining the Growth of Public Sector Employment Since 2015; Treasury Board salary data tabled in Parliament, Dec 2025; Fraser Institute, Examining the Growth of Public Sector Employment Since 2015 (Nov 2025: 950,000 jobs, 328,200 in public administration).

Exhibit C · The provinces and cities

$361 billion. That’s what every government
paid itself in 2024.

+24%
growth in what every government paid its own people, 2020 to 2024. Federal, provincial and local: $292B to $361B.
+17.5%
growth in the cost of living over the same four years. Their payroll beat it by a mile.
$16,000Per taxpayer, every year
+$69BAdded in just four years
9 of 10Provinces where government jobs grew faster than private ones
Every government’s payrollFederal, provincial, local · $292.3B (2020) → $361.2B (2024)
+24%
Cost of living, same yearsStatistics Canada CPI
+17.5%

How much of your province works for government

Newfoundland and LabradorShare of all jobs that are government jobs, 2025
30.5%
Prince Edward Island
29.6%
Canada
21.6%
Ontario
19.7%
AlbertaThe lowest
18.5%

One province, up close: British Columbia

B.C. government staffFull-time equivalents, 2015–16 → 2025–26 · +153,604
+54%
B.C. populationSame years
+19.6%
B.C. private-sector jobsIncluding self-employed
+16.8%

This is the number Ottawa’s receipt can’t show. Provinces, hospitals, school boards, universities and city halls together pay far more in wages than the federal government does. Every level grew, and most ran deficits doing it. In Ontario alone, 404,922 public employees were paid over $100,000 last year.

Manitoba was the only province where private-sector jobs kept up. Everywhere else, government grew faster than the economy paying for it.

The fix

  1. 01Every province publishes one payroll number a year, all in.
  2. 02No province hires faster than its population grows.

Sources: Statistics Canada, Canadian Government Finance Statistics for consolidated governments, Table 10-10-0147-01 (compensation of employees, 2020–2024, 2024 preliminary); Statistics Canada CPI; Fraser Institute, Government Spending, Public Sector Employment, and Labour Market Crowding Out in Canada (2026, provincial shares); Fraser Institute, Examining the Growth of Public Sector Employment Since 2015 (provinces vs private sector); Fraser Institute on B.C. government FTEs, 2015–16 to 2025–26; Ontario Public Sector Salary Disclosure 2025. Per-taxpayer figures divide by the 22.57 million people who owed income tax in 2024 (Canada Revenue Agency).

Exhibit D · The asylum system

$3.5 billion a year.
Every month they don’t decide, you pay.

$3.5B
a year from Ottawa alone: processing, health care, housing and legal aid. Provinces and cities pay on top.
300K+
claims waiting for a decision. Every month one waits is another month of health care and housing.
65%Waiting longer than a year
$155Per taxpayer, per year, federal only
4×Claimant health care in four years · $211M (2020–21) → $896M (2024–25)
Processing claims~$16,500 each × ~108,000 new claims
~$1.8B
Health care (IFHP)For 623,000 people, mostly claimants
~$1.1B
HousingHotels, shelters, payments to cities
~$0.4–0.8B
Legal aidOngoing federal funding
~$44M

Why it keeps climbing: every month a claim sits in the backlog is another month of health care and housing for someone who hasn’t paid in yet. Health coverage alone went from $211 million in 2020–21 to $896 million in 2024–25. Since 2017, more than $2 billion has gone to housing claimants.

What it doesn’t include: provinces and cities pay separately for shelters, schools and welfare. Quebec alone put its 2023 cost at $576.9 million.

The fix

  1. 01Decide claims in months, not years.
  2. 02Deport people whose claims fail.

Sources: IRCC committee briefings (2024–2025); Parliamentary Budget Officer, IFHP projections (2026) and asylum processing costs (2024); Budget 2024. Processing total is our estimate: PBO’s average cost per claim × 2025 new claims. Rounded.

Exhibit E · Every time Ottawa steps in

They quote you one price.
You pay another.

25×
ArriveCAN’s first contract was $2.35 million. The app cost about $59.5 million, and nobody can say exactly.
$864
per taxpayer, every year, on outside consultants and contractors. 2024–25.
$19.5BSpent on outside services, 2024–25
2.3×What it was in 2015–16
2Prime ministers who promised to cut it. 2015 and 2025

Project by project · biggest first

Six projects. Both parties. Same story.

$84.5B
The navy’s new warshipsBudget set in 2008

To design and build 15 ships first budgeted at $26.2 billion. That’s 3.2× the price. Over their whole life: $306 billion.

$5.1B+
Phoenix pay system2016 to today

Spent fixing a pay system budgeted at $309 million and sold as a money-saver. Its replacement is estimated at more than $4.2 billion, before departments pay to switch.

$4.6B
COVID benefits2020 to 2022

Paid to people who weren’t eligible. Another $27.4 billion should be checked, the Auditor General said. About $2.3 billion had come back by summer 2022.

$209M
McKinsey2011 to 2023

97 contracts. About 70% handed out without competition. The Auditor General found the rules were often ignored.

$76M
Federal green-tech fund2017 to 2023

Approved in 90 cases where conflict-of-interest rules weren’t followed. Another $59 million went to 10 projects that didn’t qualify. Ottawa shut the fund down.

$59.5M
ArriveCAN2020 to 2024

For an app. The first contract skipped competition. The winner then helped write the requirements for the next $25 million contract.

Both parties. The warship budget was set in 2008 and Phoenix was planned in 2009, under the Conservatives. Phoenix launched, ArriveCAN was built and outside spending more than doubled under the Liberals. McKinsey got contracts under both.

What we’re not saying: the Auditor General didn’t find bribes. She found missing records and broken rules. Treasury Board says most of the growth in outside services is engineering for shipbuilding and health care for refugee claimants. And COVID money got out fast, which she said it did.

The fix

  1. 01Do fewer things. Before Ottawa takes on a job, show why people, provinces or companies can’t.Our position
  2. 02Publish the first quote next to the final bill, on every big project.Our position
  3. 03Write down every reason a contract skipped bidding.Auditor General, ArriveCAN, 2024
  4. 04Follow the rules that already exist.Auditor General, June 2025: “I don’t believe the government needs more procurement rules”

Sources: Auditor General of Canada, Report 1 — ArriveCAN, Feb 2024; Report 5 — Professional Services Contracts (McKinsey), June 2024; Report 6 — Sustainable Development Technology Canada, June 2024; Report 10 — Specific COVID-19 Benefits, Dec 2022; Modernizing the Pay System, 2026 ($4.2B replacement estimate). Parliamentary Budget Officer, The Life Cycle Cost of the Canadian Surface Combatants, Oct 2022 ($26.2B 2008 budget, $84.5B design and build, $306B life cycle). Phoenix: federal officials via The Canadian Press, June 2025 ($5.1B); Government of Canada figures via The Canadian Press, 2018 ($309.2M original cost). Public Accounts of Canada via The Canadian Press, Nov 2025 ($19.5B external professional and special services in 2024–25; about $8.3B in 2015–16); Treasury Board Secretariat (reasons for growth). $19.5B ÷ 22.57M taxpayers (CRA, 2024) ≈ $864.

Exhibit F · The Prime Minister’s old company

He runs the country.
He still owns a piece of Brookfield.

Mark Carney
Prime Minister
Former Brookfield chair
3×
Brookfield Corp.’s profit to shareholders, first nine months: US$564M in 2025, US$1.77B in 2026.
0
Brookfield shares he sold. They sit in a blind trust, and he still owns what’s in it.
7Times officials flagged a conflict with his own money and he stayed in. Out of 13 flags.

Brookfield Corp. profit to shareholders · by quarter · US$

0$400M$800M$1.2BQ1Q2Q3Q42026 · $1.3B2025 · $219M0$400M$800M$1.2BQ1Q2Q3Q42026 · $1.3B2025 · $219M

20262025

Every quarter of 2026 beat the same quarter of 2025. First nine months: US$564M → US$1.77B. That’s 3×.

+US$1.08 billion in one quarter.

What we know: before politics he chaired Brookfield. His holdings weren’t sold, they went into a blind trust. He still owns what’s in it. An ethics screen is supposed to keep him out of Brookfield decisions, and it’s run by people who work for him.

What we’re not saying: that a government decision made him money. Nobody can prove that either way, and that’s the problem. Much of the third-quarter jump is one-off accounting, not a policy windfall.

And his friend’s company · Telesat

Mark Carney

$2.3 billion to a friend of 20 years. No ethics screen until last week.

$2.3B
Telesat defence contractAug. 2026

Arctic military satellites, and it can grow to $2.7 billion. Telesat’s CEO, Dan Goldberg, has been Carney’s friend for nearly 20 years. He was at Carney’s swearing-in.

$2.55B
Another Telesat contractJuly 31, 2026

In Defence’s own records: sole-sourced, and “omitted from a previous public disclosure.”

0
Ethics screens on TelesatUntil Nov. 14, 2026

Brookfield got a screen in 2025. His friend’s company didn’t. Carney asked for one last Friday, three months after the contract.

2006
Who hired GoldbergMichael Sabia, then CEO of Telesat’s owner, BCE

Carney made Sabia head of the public service in 2025. Sabia’s office is the one that said the contract followed proper process.

What we’re not saying: that Carney steered the contract. His office says he took no part, and Goldberg says he never asked for anything. Telesat is a Canadian rival to Starlink, and Ottawa backed it before he arrived.

What we are saying: the Prime Minister’s close friends shouldn’t need a news story to get screened.

The rules they set for themselves

Break the ethics law: no penalty. What they own: hidden.

Every MP has to tell the ethics commissioner what they own. You get to see what it is. You don’t get to see what it’s worth.

$0
Fine for breaking the conflict-of-interest lawConflict of Interest Act

The only fines are for late paperwork, up to $500. Break the rules themselves and nothing happens. Trudeau broke them twice: a paid island vacation from someone lobbying his government, then SNC-Lavalin. His finance minister broke them three ways over WE Charity.

Hidden
What their holdings are worthThe public registry

The public summary lists the source and nature of what MPs own, “but not the value.” So you can’t see who got rich in office. In the U.S., you can at least see dollar ranges.

26
MPs with no public disclosureAs of April 22, 2026

14 Liberals, 9 Conservatives, 3 Bloc. One was a cabinet minister, seven months past her deadline. The commissioner “generally does not” fine late filers.

Who hadn’t filed. All 26, by party. See the names ↓

Liberal: Sima Acan, Karim Bardeesy, Paul Connors, Michael Coteau, Anju Dhillon, Philip Earle, Claude Guay, Mandy Gull-Masty (cabinet minister), Emma-Lee Harrison Hill, Arielle Kayabaga, Ron McKinnon, Zoë Royer, Louis Villeneuve, John Zerucelli. Conservative: Amanpreet Singh Gill, Dalwinder Gill, Tamara Kronis, Jagsharan Singh Mahal, Shuvaloy Majumdar, Warren Steinley, Matthew Strauss, Corey Tochor, Brad Vis. Bloc Québécois: Mario Beaulieu, Marilène Gill, Andréanne Larouche.

What we’re not saying: that late filers are hiding something. Many catch up. Every party is on the list.

What we are saying: rules with no penalty aren’t rules. Show us what it’s worth, and fine them when they break it.

Who’s watching them · From Ottawa’s own budgets

The outlets covering Ottawa. Paid by Ottawa.

Between CBC and help for private newsrooms, Ottawa spends over $1.7 billion a year on media. Budget 2026 added more, and opened the door to newsrooms owned by Bell, Rogers and Quebecor.

$1.7B
A year in federal money for CBC and news subsidies, 2025.
$75
Per taxpayer, every year.
$1.38B
CBC/Radio-Canada2026–27

Plus $300 million more over two years in Budget 2026.

$501M
Tax credit on newsroom salariesBudget 2026 · five years, then $85M a year

Ottawa covers 35% of a journalist’s wages, up to $29,750 each. Now open to private TV and radio newsrooms, including those owned by Bell, Rogers and Quebecor.

$41M
Local Journalism Initiative, every yearMade permanent in Budget 2026

Federally funded reporter positions in hundreds of newsrooms.

$102M
From Google, by lawOnline News Act · January 2026

Not tax money. Ottawa passed a law that made Google pay it.

What we’re not saying: that reporters are told what to write, or that one side is bought. Outlets that hammer the government take the money too.

What we are saying: when the people holding power to account are paid by it, you deserve to know. On every story.

More for the CBC than for CSIS. Or Parks Canada. Or StatCan.

This year your public broadcaster gets more than the spy agency, every national park, and the agency that counts the country. Even without the top-up, it still beats all three.

CBC/Radio-Canada$1.38B in the Main Estimates, plus this year’s $150M top-up
$1.53B
Parks CanadaEvery national park and historic site
$1.29B
Statistics CanadaThe agency that counts the country
$1.06B
CSISThe spy agency guarding against foreign interference
$1.01B
Auditor GeneralAudits all of Ottawa
$136M

Fund what only the CBC does. News in eight Indigenous languages in the North, where it’s often the only source. Emergency radio. French outside Quebec. Pay for that, all of it. The rest is a national entertainment network competing with private outlets for ads and staff, and they already make the shows.

Canadian music, by quota. You don’t get a say.

35%
Canadian music, by lawCRTC · commercial radio

At least 35% of the popular music on commercial radio has to be Canadian. The regulator picks the rule. You get what fits it.

15%
What streamers were told to payCRTC, May 2026

Of their Canadian revenue, for Canadian content. Then Ottawa backed down. In July it told the Federal Court of Appeal it will scrap even the original 5% levy and pay with government money instead. Same subsidy. Now it’s your money.

What we’re not saying: that Canadian artists don’t deserve an audience. Some of the best bands anywhere came out of this country.

What we are saying: people find the music they love themselves. A quota mostly helps the artists already big enough to get played.

The fix

  1. 01Sell it all. A blind trust isn’t enough.
  2. 02Publish every decision the conflict screen kept him out of.
  3. 03No paid speeches, board seats or book deals for five years after leaving office.Our position
  4. 04Screen the friends too. Any company run by a prime minister’s close friend goes on the conflict screen before a dollar moves.Our position
  5. 05Publish what they own and what it’s worth, every year. Real fines for breaking the ethics law.Our position
  6. 06Any outlet that takes federal money says so on every story.Our position
  7. 07Fund what only the CBC does. The North, emergency radio, French outside Quebec. Cut the rest.Our position
  8. 08Let listeners choose. No quotas on what you hear, and no tax money replacing a levy streamers were never going to pay.Our position

Sources: Brookfield Corporation Q3 2026 results (SEC Form 6-K); Brookfield Corporation quarterly results, Q1 2025 to Q2 2026 (net income attributable to Brookfield shareholders: 2025 US$73M, $272M, $219M, $743M; 2026 US$102M, $364M); Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner, public registry (blind trust and ethics screen, July 2025); House of Commons Standing Committee on Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics, testimony of the Prime Minister’s chief of staff, Nov. 20, 2025 (13 files flagged; the ethics screen applied on 6); Brookfield Asset Management Q3 2026 results ($2.0B non-cash Oaktree gain).; Public Services and Procurement Canada and Defence Investment Agency, Aug. 4, 2026 (Telesat contract about $2.3B, options to about $2.7B); National Defence proactive contract disclosure via SpaceQ, 2026 (Telesat LEO, about $2.55B, July 31, 2026, sole-sourced, omitted from a previous disclosure); CTV News and The Canadian Press, Nov. 14, 2026 (Carney asks ethics commissioner for a screen on Goldberg and Telesat; friends for nearly two decades; Goldberg at the swearing-in); The Wire Report, Sept. 2025 (Sabia, then BCE chief, hired Goldberg in 2006); Prime Minister’s Office, June 11, 2025 (Sabia named Clerk of the Privy Council); Conflict of Interest Act and Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner (administrative monetary penalties up to $500 for reporting failures; no penalty for contraventions of substantive rules, CTV News, May 2021); Ethics Commissioner, Trudeau Report, Dec. 2017 (Aga Khan), and Trudeau II Report, Aug. 2019 (SNC-Lavalin); Ethics Commissioner, Morneau Report, May 2021 (three sections); Ethics Commissioner, Summary of Members’ obligations (public disclosure summary sets out the source and nature, but not the value, of income, assets and liabilities of $10,000 or more); Global News, April 2026 (26 MPs without public disclosures as of April 22, 2026: 14 Liberal, 9 Conservative, 3 Bloc Québécois; Gull-Masty about seven months past the deadline; commissioner “generally does not issue an administrative monetary penalty”); Hill Times, March 2026, from the 2026–27 Main Estimates (CBC/Radio-Canada $1.38B, down from $1.58B); Budget 2026 via Nieman Lab and The Canadian Press, Nov. 2026 ($300M over two years for CBC/Radio-Canada; Canadian Journalism Labour Tax Credit $501M over five years and $85M ongoing, 35% up to $29,750 per employee, extended to private audio and audiovisual news organizations; Local Journalism Initiative $134M over four years from 2027–28, then $41M a year); The Hub, April 2025 (over $1.7B a year between media support programs and CBC funding); $1.7B ÷ 22.57M taxpayers (CRA, 2024) ≈ $75; Canadian Heritage, Question Period note, 2026 (Google paid $102M to the Canadian Journalism Collective in January 2026 under the Online News Act); 2026–27 Main Estimates (CBC/Radio-Canada $1,383,252,311, via The Hill Times, March 4, 2026); Radio World, Nov. 2026 (Budget 2026: $150M for CBC/Radio-Canada in each of 2026–27 and 2027–28); Minister of Public Safety, Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security, May 28, 2026 (CSIS: $1 billion, up $32.7M on $980.1M); Minister of Environment, Standing Committee on Environment, 2026 (Parks Canada Main Estimates $1.29B); Statistics Canada 2026–27 Departmental Plan (planned spending $1,056,027,729); Office of the Auditor General 2026–27 Departmental Plan (planned spending $136,428,682); World Press Freedom Canada, Nov. 20, 2024 (CBC North in eight Indigenous languages); CRTC Radio Regulations (35% Canadian popular music on commercial radio); CRTC news release, May 2026 (online broadcasters to contribute 15%, including the 5% base contribution); Department of Justice letter to the Federal Court of Appeal, July 17, 2026, via Michael Geist (government intends to eliminate the base contribution and replace it with government funding)

Bonuses, pensions, payrolls, asylum, ArriveCAN, Phoenix, Brookfield. Every exhibit comes down to three questions about your money.

The fix

  1. 01Who got it? Every contract over $1 million published with the company, its owners and the amount. No hiding behind staffing middlemen.
  2. 02Was it competed? Sole-source deals need a public reason, signed by a named official. Bidders can’t write their own requirements.
  3. 03What did we get? Every program reports what it delivered against what it promised, on the date it promised. Anyone appointed close to power files full disclosures.

1867 → today · Who has run Canada

Two parties. 159 years.
Mostly one.

59%Of the time since Confederation, Canada has had a Liberal prime minister · 94 of 159 years
69%Of the years since 1963, a Liberal prime minister · 44 of 64 years
0Days any other party has governed

New faces. Same two parties. No thank you.

13 of Carney’s 28 ministers sat at Trudeau’s cabinet table. New leader, same room.

And the other party? · Harper, 2006 to 2015

The Conservatives won’t save you either. Here’s their record.

$147B
Added to the federal debt2006 to 2015

Seven deficits in a row, 2008–09 to 2014–15. About $6,500 per taxpayer, before a dollar of Trudeau’s.

2.4×
Temporary foreign workers2005 to 2012

From 141,000 to 338,000. In 2006 Ottawa opened more low-wage jobs to the program. In 2013, RBC staff were laid off after training the foreign workers who replaced them.

3.2×
Warships and PhoenixStarted 2008 and 2009

The navy’s $26.2 billion warship budget and the Phoenix pay system both began under Harper. See Exhibit E.

0
Immigration numbers promised today2025 to now

Their 2025 platform promised to cut permanent immigration to Harper-era levels, roughly 250,000 to 280,000 a year. As of October 2026 they still haven’t put a number on it.

What we’re not saying: the 2008 deficits came in a global recession, and the other parties wanted to spend more, not less. Harper’s immigration levels were lower than today’s.

Both parties: in 2014 Justin Trudeau attacked Harper for growing the temporary foreign worker program. As prime minister, he grew work permits far faster.

Why neither party fixes it · Our position

Ottawa cut spending four years in a row before 2015. Since 2015 it’s up 86%. Every program Ottawa adds creates voters who depend on it. Cut it, and you lose.

+43%
Federal public service2015 to 2024

From 257,034 to 367,772 people. From 0.72% of Canadians to 0.90%. Ottawa now plans to trim about 40,000 by 2029.

+86%
Federal program spending2015–16 to 2024–25

From $263.6 billion to $489.9 billion a year. Prices rose about 27% over the same years.

4
Years in a row spending was cut2010–11 to 2013–14

The government that cut it lost in 2015. In 2025, Poilievre promised to cut public-service jobs and lost his Ottawa seat. That’s his own explanation.

The fix

  1. 01No vote for any party that won’t answer for every number on this page.
  2. 02Pledge to show up and decline your ballot. No more lesser of two evils.

Days in office from each prime minister’s swearing-in, July 1, 1867 to November 15, 2026. Conservative includes the Liberal-Conservative, Unionist (1917–1921) and Progressive Conservative governments. Sources: Library of Parliament, Prime Ministers of Canada; The Logic and Hill Times, May 13, 2025 (Carney cabinet: 28 ministers, 15 new); Privy Council Office, Guide to Canadian Ministries since Confederation. Conservative record: Department of Finance, Fiscal Reference Tables 2025, Table 1 (accumulated deficit $481.5B in 2005–06, $628.9B in 2014–15; deficits 2008–09 to 2014–15); $147.4B ÷ 22.57M taxpayers (CRA, 2024) ≈ $6,530. Citizenship and Immigration Canada, Facts and Figures 2012 (temporary foreign workers present: about 141,000 in 2005, 338,189 in 2012); House of Commons, Minister Jason Kenney, April 29, 2014; CBC News, April 2013 (RBC). Parliamentary Budget Officer, 2017 and 2022 (warship budget). Conservative Party platform 2025, via Global News; Citizenship and Immigration Canada via Maclean’s (permanent residents: 251,642 in 2006, 280,681 in 2010); House of Commons Question Period, Oct. 22, 2026, via Immigration News Canada (no alternative target released); Justin Trudeau, Toronto Star op-ed, 2014, via The Hub. Why neither party fixes it: Treasury Board Secretariat, Population of the Federal Public Service and Question Period notes, 2025 (257,034 in 2015; 367,772 in 2024; 0.72% to 0.90% of the population; about 40,000 positions to go by March 2029); Department of Finance, Fiscal Reference Tables 2025, Table 1 (program expenses $263.6B in 2015–16, $489.9B in 2024–25; lower each year from 2010–11 to 2013–14); Statistics Canada CPI (126.6 in 2015, 160.9 in 2024); CBC News, July 12, 2025 (Poilievre on losing Carleton).

The poster series

Twenty-two numbers. No thank you.

Print them, post them, put them in a window. Every number is real, dated and sourced on this page.
See them all, ready to download →

How to say no

Don’t stay home. Show up and say NO.

Staying home looks like you don’t care. A declined ballot is a NO they have to count and report.

  1. 01

    Go to your polling station.

    Bring ID like any other election day.

  2. 02

    Take the ballot. Hand it back.

    Say it out loud: “I decline my ballot.”

  3. 03

    They have to count it.

    It goes in its own envelope and is reported on election night as “ballots declined by voters.”

31,399Ontarians declined their ballot in 2014. The most since 1975, after one campaign told people how.
4Provinces where you can do it: Ontario, Alberta, Manitoba, Saskatchewan.
0Federal elections where you can. Not yet.

The fix

  1. 01Put a real NO on the federal ballot, and report the count on election night.Elections Canada recommended this itself

Sources: Elections Ontario, glossary (“ballots declined by voters”); Elections Ontario 2014 results via CTV News (31,399 declined, most since 1975); OpenCouncil.ca (provinces that allow declined ballots; federal recommendation by Elections Canada).

The pledge

I’ll show up and say no thank you.

One pledge: I’ll go to the polls and decline my ballot, and I’ll push for a real NO on the federal ballot. Add your name, pick what you’re done paying for, and we’ll make you a sign.

I’m saying no thank you to

Add your name. Get your sign. Show up and say no.

Your poster updates as you type.

About this site

Who’s behind this? People paying the bill.

Who

Canadians who got tired of choosing the lesser of two evils. Not a party, not a candidate, not a lobby. We don’t put our names on it because the numbers should stand on their own.

Money

Nobody funds this. No ads, no party money, no donations, nothing for sale. No analytics either: we don’t track you, and nothing you type on this page leaves your browser.

How we check

Every number is real, dated and sourced, from Ottawa’s own departments, the budget officer, the auditor general and Statistics Canada first. Tap “Sources” under any section. Where something is our position rather than a fact, we say so.

Corrections

Found a number that’s wrong? Send the source to nothankyou@saynothankyou.ca. If we got it wrong, we fix it and log it here, dated.

  1. No corrections yet.

Last updated .

Sources